Bringing a security to life: investment banking
Lead manager, syndicate, firm underwriting and fees: how an issue goes from a need for money to listed securities.
Lesson 49 min
By the end of this lesson
- Describe the role of the lead manager, the syndicate and firm underwriting
- Calculate the net proceeds an issuer receives after the fee
- Explain the bank’s conflict of interest over the issue price
In this lesson4
A share or a bond does not exist until the day an issuer creates and sells it. Between a company's need for money and securities trading on an exchange there is a profession: investment banking. The skill in this lesson: describing the role of the lead manager, the syndicate and firm underwriting, and calculating what the issuer really receives.
What an investment bank does
The profession has two broad families. Capital markets: helping a state or a company issue shares or bonds on the primary market. Advisory: mergers, acquisitions, public offers. In the CEMAC, advising issuers is one of the functions that require a COSUMAF professional card (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, art. 13), and it is one or more brokerage firms that file a takeover bid with the COSUMAF (art. 224; see Public offers and mergers).
In the United States, the SEC describes "underwriters" as the investment banks that manage and sell the IPO for the company: they gather indications of interest, recommend a price, and the issuer decides (SEC, "Investing in an IPO").
Lead manager, syndicate, firm underwriting
In the CEMAC, the issuer appoints one or two brokerage firms to handle the placement. The appointed firm, the lead manager, may form a placement syndicate with other brokers and banks; it centralises subscriptions in a dedicated account, reports to the COSUMAF every Friday during the placement, and the centralising institution transfers the proceeds to the issuer within eight calendar days of the close (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, art. 171 to 173). Before opening, a "pre-placement" period allows statements of intent to be gathered, but not firm orders (art. 170).
Firm underwriting
The syndicate's irrevocable commitment to buy any securities in an issue that find no buyer, so that the issuer is sure to place everything.
The regulation defines firm underwriting as the "firm and irrevocable" commitment to acquire the securities before they are offered to the public; the syndicate then sells them on the market (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, definitions). Government securities have their own intermediaries: the primary dealers in Treasury securities, credit institutions that alone may take part in BEAC auctions (BEAC, primary dealers' specifications; see Auctions).
From memory: what risk does the syndicate take when it gives a firm underwriting commitment?
The life of an issue
Follow a fictional bond issue by the company Okoumé Énergie, from the need for money to listing.
A need for 5 billion
The fictional company Okoumé Énergie wants 5.0 billion FCFA for a power plant. It chooses to borrow from the public: 500,000 bonds of 10,000 FCFA at 6.5% over 5 years.
The COSUMAF visa implies "neither approval of the merits of the transaction, nor authentication of the accounting and financial information" (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, definitions). The investment bank prepares the file; the regulator checks that it informs; nobody guarantees the investor that the bond is good.
What Okoumé receives, what the syndicate risksFictional
Fictional bond issue: 5,000,000,000 FCFA, in bonds of 10,000 FCFA.
- The number of bonds. 5,000,000,000 ÷ 10,000 = 500,000 bonds.
- Subscriptions. The public subscribes 4,600,000,000 FCFA, i.e. 460,000 bonds.
- Firm underwriting. 400,000,000 FCFA is missing, i.e. 40,000 bonds, which the syndicate buys.
- The fee. Fictional fee of 1.2% of the amount: 5,000,000,000 × 0.012 = 60,000,000 FCFA.
- Net proceeds. Okoumé receives 5,000,000,000 − 60,000,000 = 4,940,000,000 FCFA.
- The syndicate's risk. If it sells its 40,000 bonds at 98% of face value, it loses 2% of 400,000,000, i.e. 8,000,000 FCFA: more than an eighth of the fee.
Writing for the amount of the issue, for the fee rate and for the net proceeds the issuer receives:
The price, a conflict to manage
The SEC puts it plainly: banks have an interest in a high price, since their pay is "typically a percentage of the offering price", but they must also sell the whole issue to their clients, who prefer a low price; too low a price costs the issuer money (SEC, "Investing in an IPO"). The investment bank therefore serves two parties at once. That is why advice to issuers is separated from the teams advising investors by an information barrier.
The amounts and fee rate in the example are fictional. No source read publishes the fees charged on BVMAC issues. A successful issue says nothing about the securities' future return for the investor.
Without looking back: an issue of 2,000,000,000 FCFA, a fee of 1.5%. How much does the issuer receive?
Your turn
Read next: SEC, Investor Bulletin « Investing in an IPO »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.