Skip to content
Criée

Implied volatility and the smile

Recover the volatility that gives back an observed price, then read what its shape across strikes says about the market.

Lesson 129 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate an implied volatility by bisection from an observed price
  • Read a volatility smile or skew across strike prices
  • Explain what the VIX index measures
In this lesson3

The Black-Scholes formula turns an assumed volatility into a price. On an options market, you do the reverse: the price is on the screen, and you look for the volatility that gives it back. That number sums up what the market expects. What you will learn: calculate an implied volatility from an observed price, and read what its variation from one strike to another tells you.

Inverting the formula

The OIC, the education body of the US options clearing house (OCC), defines implied volatility as a measure of how much the marketplace expects the underlying to move, based on the price of the option; historical volatility, by contrast, measures actual price changes over a given period (OIC, "Volatility & the Greeks").

Implied volatility

The volatility which, entered into the Black-Scholes formula with the four other observed inputs, gives back exactly the option's market price.

In plain wordsThe price of umbrellas

At the market entrance, the price of umbrellas says a lot about the rain people expect: the more they are willing to pay, the more they fear a downpour. Implied volatility makes the same reading: the option's price is on display, and you look for how much agitation in the share price it assumes. Try a value; if the price it gives is too high, lower it, if too low, raise it, until you land on the displayed price. It is not a sure forecast: it is what buyers are willing to pay, fear included.

The formula does not let you isolate volatility by simple algebra. But an option's price always rises with volatility (vega is positive): each price corresponds to a single volatility, which can be found by successive trials. The simplest method is bisection: start from an interval that contains the answer, calculate the price at the midpoint, keep the half where the solution lies, and repeat.

A fictional call trades at 1,200 XAFFictional

Fictional share at 10,000 XAF, one-year call with a strike of 10,000 XAF, continuous rate 4.879%. The call trades at 1,200 XAF. Which volatility gives back this price? Starting interval: 10% to 50%.

StepIntervalMidpointBlack-Scholes price at midpoint (XAF)Decision
110% to 50%30%1,417.30too expensive: keep the lower half
210% to 30%20%1,038.63too cheap: keep the upper half
320% to 30%25%1,227.51too expensive: lower half
420% to 25%22.5%1,132.89too cheap: upper half
522.5% to 25%23.75%1,180.16too cheap: upper half
623.75% to 25%24.375%1,203.83too expensive: lower half
723.75% to 24.375%24.0625%1,191.99too cheap: upper half

Each step halves the interval. Carrying on gives an implied volatility of 24.27%.

Check with vega: at 20%, the call is worth 1,038.63 XAF and its vega is 37.60 XAF per point. The gap is 161.37 XAF, so 161.37 ÷ 37.60 = 4.29 points: about 24.29%, very close.

At step 3, the price at the midpoint (1,227.51 XAF) is above the observed price (1,200 XAF). Why keep the lower half of the interval?

The volatility smile

If Black-Scholes described the market perfectly, every option on the same share with the same expiry would give the same implied volatility: a single, constant volatility, by assumption. That is not what we observe.

The OIC calls "skew" the difference between the implied volatilities of out-of-the-money, at-the-money and in-the-money options with the same expiry. The curve drawn against the strike forms a "smile" when out-of-the-money puts and calls both have higher volatility than at the money, or a "smirk" when only one side is raised. According to the OIC, the phenomenon became more pronounced after the crash of 19 October 1987; a downside smirk can come from investors protecting their portfolios against a falling market, and skew is ultimately a product of supply and demand (OIC, "Volatility Skew and Options: An Overview", 2023).

Volatility smile

The curve of implied volatilities of options with the same expiry, drawn against their strike. Flat if Black-Scholes were exact; raised at both ends (smile) or on one side only (skew).

Fictional one-year puts on the share at 10,000 XAFFictional

Strike (XAF)Observed put (XAF)Price at 20% volatility (XAF)Implied volatility
8,0002147028%
9,00034823424%
10,00056256220%
11,0009971,07618%
12,0001,6521,75017%

The put with an 8,000 XAF strike, protection against a 20% fall, costs three times its constant-volatility price. Implied volatility falls as the strike rises: this is a skew, the downside smirk described by the OIC.

What the skew says about the assumptions: the market charges more for large falls than a single volatility would. A Federal Reserve economist puts it this way: the model assumes the price follows geometric Brownian motion, an assumption that tends not to hold in practice, hence a "smile" in which the implied volatilities of far out-of-the-money options exceed those of at-the-money options (Weinberg, Federal Reserve, IFDP 706, 2001). Volatility that changes, prices that jump, crashes more frequent than the normal distribution allows: the assumptions seen in the lesson the Black-Scholes formula give way, and the smile keeps the record.

The VIX, the implied volatility of an index

Cboe launched its volatility index, the VIX, in 1993, originally designed to measure the market's expectation of 30-day volatility implied by at-the-money options on the S&P 100 index. Since 2003, it has been based on the S&P 500 index and aggregates the prices of puts and calls over a wide range of strikes. It measures the 30-day expected volatility of the S&P 500 index, from options expiring between 23 and 37 days and US Treasury rates (Cboe, "Volatility Index Methodology: Cboe Volatility Index").

The VIX does not invert Black-Scholes option by option: it combines the whole range of strikes, and so the whole smile, into a single number. The idea stays the same: read in option prices the volatility the market expects.

The BVMAC does not list options (BVMAC, products and services): no implied volatility can therefore be read on the CEMAC exchange. The prices in this lesson are fictional.

Enter 1,200 XAF in the calculator's implied volatility field and compare it with the 24.27% found by bisection.

Option price with Black-Scholes

Call

1,038.6271

Put
562.4382
d1 · d2
0.3439 · 0.1439
N(d1) · N(d2)
0.6346 · 0.5572
Delta (call · put)
0.6346 · -0.3654
Gamma
0.000188
Vega (per volatility point)
37.6029
Theta per day (call · put)
-1.7396 · -0.4665
Rho (per rate point, call · put)
53.0695 · -42.1686

Call value against the price

Blue line: value today. Dashes: payoff at expiry. Coral line: current price. The gap between the two curves is the time value.

Implied volatility

Volatility that gives back this price20.00%

Formulad1 = [ln(S/K) + (r + σ²/2)T] / (σ√T); d2 = d1 − σ√T. Call = S N(d1) − K e^(−rT) N(d2); put = K e^(−rT) N(−d2) − S N(−d1). European options, no dividend, constant volatility and rate. A learning example, not advice.

From memory: how do you find a call's implied volatility from its price, and what does a volatility smile show about the Black-Scholes assumptions?

Your turn

At 25%, the model gives 1,227.51 XAF for a call observed at 1,200 XAF. For the next step, you must...

1At 25%, the model gives 1,227.51 XAF for a call observed at 1,200 XAF. For the next step, you must...

Low-strike puts have higher implied volatility. This skew suggests...

2Low-strike puts have higher implied volatility. This skew suggests...

The VIX measures the expected volatility of the S&P 500 index over...

3The VIX measures the expected volatility of the S&P 500 index over...

If Black-Scholes described the market perfectly, the curve of implied volatilities against strike would be...

4If Black-Scholes described the market perfectly, the curve of implied volatilities against strike would be...

Read next: Options Industry Council (OCC), « Volatility Skew and Options: An Overview » (2023)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further