A speech, uncertainty and prices
Uncertainty has a price: the risk premium. One sentence by Mario Draghi lowered government rates in 2012.
Lesson 79 min
By the end of this lesson
- Work out the price of a share when the risk premium changes
- Convert a change in rates into basis points
- Explain why uncertainty lowers a price without changing the dividend
In this lesson4
A president speaks, a minister announces a tax, a central bank governor says one sentence: prices sometimes move within the minute. A statement acts in two ways. It can change what the market expects (lesson 2). And it can change how sure the market is of what it expects. This lesson is about the second effect: uncertainty has a price.
Risk premium
The extra return an investor requires to accept an uncertain investment rather than a safe one. The greater the uncertainty, the larger the premium asked, and the lower the price paid.
The same dividend, a lower price
One share, two levels of uncertaintyFictional
Kapok shares (a fictional company) should pay 500 CFA francs a year. A safe investment pays 5%. We reuse the division from lesson 1.
- Calm climate. Investors ask for a 3-point premium: 5% + 3% = 8%. Price: 500 ÷ 0.08 = 6,250 CFA francs.
- A vague speech about a tax. The expected dividend does not change, but nobody knows whether it will be hit. The premium rises to 4 points: 5% + 4% = 9%. Price: 500 ÷ 0.09 ≈ 5,556 CFA francs.
- The fall. (6,250 − 5,556) ÷ 6,250 ≈ 11%. The price falls by 11% without a single franc of dividend having disappeared.
- The clarification. If the government makes clear no tax will come, the premium can come down again, and the price rise.
From memory: expected dividend 600 CFA francs, safe investment at 5%, premium of 5 points. What is the price in this model?
Writing for the dividend expected each year, for the return on a safe investment and for the risk premium, the model price is:
In the order book
Uncertainty also shows in the orders. Buyers lower their limits or wait, some pull out: there are fewer trades, at a lower price. Follow Kapok's order book during a vague speech, then after a clarification. The engine recalculates the price and the quantity traded at each step.
- Awa 4010,200Hervé 50
- Chantal 3010,100Didier 30
- Fabrice 5010,000Esther 40
- Grâce 309,900Bertrand 30
Computed by the @criee/marche engine (auction)
70 shares traded
A quiet day. Orders cluster around 10,000 CFA francs.
A sentence that moved rates
On 26 July 2012 in London, in the middle of the euro area debt crisis, the President of the ECB, Mario Draghi, said: "Within our mandate, the ECB is ready to do whatever it takes to preserve the euro. And believe me, it will be enough." (speech, ECB).
The ECB measured the effect. That same day, the gap between the ten-year rate of Spain or Italy and that of Germany fell by 40 basis points, that of Portugal and Ireland by 20, that of Greece by 10. The following announcements on the bond purchase programme (2 August and 6 September 2012) are estimated to have lowered Italian and Spanish two-year rates by about 200 basis points (ECB, Monthly Bulletin, May 2014). No bond had been bought yet: the sentence reduced the fear of the euro breaking up, and so the risk premium demanded from these states.
Basis point
One hundredth of a percentage point: 0.01%. A rate that goes from 4.00% to 4.40% has risen by 40 basis points.
Without looking above: on 26 July 2012, by how much did Italy's ten-year rate gap with Germany fall, and why was a single sentence enough?
Measuring uncertainty
Uncertainty cannot be seen directly, but it can be approximated. Economists build an economic policy uncertainty index by counting, in ten large US daily newspapers, the articles that discuss uncertainty about economic policy (Economic Policy Uncertainty, methodology). No equivalent index was found for the CEMAC zone: the examples in this lesson remain general.
A statement has no mechanical effect: the same speech can reassure or worry depending on what was expected, and the effect can reverse in the following days. Buying or selling "on a speech" means betting on how others will react. Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.
Your turn
Read next: BCE, Bulletin mensuel de mai 2014, effets des annonces de 2012
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.