Skip to content
Criée

Replicating an option over one period

A price that goes up or down, shares and a loan that copy the option: its price, without any probability.

Lesson 68 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Build the replicating portfolio of an option over one period
  • Calculate an option price from Δ and the deposit
  • Explain why the probability of a rise does not enter the price
In this lesson4

What is the right to buy a share in a year's time, at today's price, worth today? Nobody knows the future price, and yet there is a single price, provided you simplify the world: in a year, the share price has only two possible values. What you will learn: build, from shares and a deposit, a portfolio that reproduces an option exactly, and derive its price from it.

Options and their payoffs at expiry are covered in "Calls and puts"; the argument below rests on no-arbitrage.

A price that goes up or down

Binomial tree

A model in which, each period, the price of the underlying is multiplied either by an up factor u or by a down factor d. Over one period, there are only two states of the world at expiry.

Cox, Ross and Rubinstein published this model in 1979 (Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 7, pp. 229-263). They thank William Sharpe for suggesting the discrete-time approach to them (Cox, Ross and Rubinstein, working paper).

A fictional share at 10,000 XAFFictional

  • Price today: 10,000 XAF. In a year: 12,000 (up, u = 1.2) or 8,000 (down, d = 0.8).
  • Risk-free rate: 5% for the year.
  • European call option, strike price 10,000, expiry one year.
  • Value of the option at expiry: 12,000 − 10,000 = 2,000 if the price rises; 0 if it falls.

Copying the option

Replicating portfolio

A portfolio of shares and a risk-free deposit (or loan) that pays exactly the same amount as the option in every state of the world.

We look for Δ\Delta shares and a deposit BB (negative if it is a loan) worth 2,000 if the price rises and 0 if it falls. The MIT OpenCourseWare 15.401 course sets up exactly this system (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, Recitation 5). Writing SS for today's price, ShS_h and SbS_b for the up and down prices, VhV_h and VbV_b for the option's values in those two states, rr for the rate per period and VV for the option price:

Δ=Vh−VbSh−SbB=Vh−Δ Sh1+rV=Δ S+B\Delta = \frac{V_h - V_b}{S_h - S_b} \qquad B = \frac{V_h - \Delta\, S_h}{1 + r} \qquad V = \Delta\, S + B

Replicating the fictional callFictional

  1. Number of shares: Δ = (2,000 − 0) ÷ (12,000 − 8,000) = 2,000 ÷ 4,000 = 0.5 share.
  2. Deposit: in a year, it must be worth 2,000 − 0.5 × 12,000 = − 4,000. That is a loan of 4,000 ÷ 1.05 = 3,809.52 XAF today.
  3. Call price: 0.5 × 10,000 − 3,809.52 = 1,190.48 XAF.
  4. Check if the price rises: 0.5 × 12,000 − 4,000 = 2,000. If it falls: 0.5 × 8,000 − 4,000 = 0. The portfolio reproduces the option in both states.

If the call sold for 1,300 XAF, you would sell it and buy the replicating portfolio for 1,190.48: 109.52 XAF collected today, and at expiry the portfolio pays exactly what you owe on the call. At 1,100 XAF, you would do the opposite: buy the call, sell the portfolio (short 0.5 share and deposit 3,809.52), and collect 90.48. Only 1,190.48 leaves no risk-free gain.

A put is replicated the same way. With the same strike, it is worth 0 if the price rises and 2,000 if it falls: Δ = (0 − 2,000) ÷ 4,000 = − 0.5 (a short sale), deposit = (0 + 0.5 × 12,000) ÷ 1.05 = 5,714.29, price = − 5,000 + 5,714.29 = 714.29 XAF.

To replicate a call over one period, do you buy or sell shares, and do you deposit or borrow?

The probability of a rise appears nowhere

The calculation never used the probability that the price rises. Whether investors put it at 90% or 10%, the price stays 1,190.48 XAF, because the replicating portfolio pays the same as the option whatever happens. Cox, Ross and Rubinstein stress it: the probability of a rise does not appear in the formula, and the call's value does not depend on investors' attitudes towards risk (Cox, Ross and Rubinstein, section 3). The MIT course likewise says this probability is not used (MIT OpenCourseWare).

The probability of a rise influences the share price, 10,000 XAF, but once that price is given, the option follows without it.

In plain wordsCopying the purchase voucher

Picture a voucher that lets you buy a sack of maize for 10,000 francs in a year. The sack will then be worth 12,000 or 8,000: the voucher will pay 2,000 or nothing. Now half a sack bought today, partly paid for with a debt that will cost 4,000 to repay, also pays 2,000 or nothing. Same result in both cases, so same price today, without having to guess whether the price will rise. Except that a real price has far more than two outcomes: the tree chains many of them together, over short periods.

The condition d < 1 + r < u

The authors require the risk-free deposit to earn more than the fall and less than the rise; otherwise an arbitrage exists with the share and the deposit alone (Cox, Ross and Rubinstein, section 3).

Two arbitrages when the condition is brokenFictional

  1. A rate of 25%, above the rise (20%): short the share, deposit 10,000 at 25%. At expiry: 12,500 in cash, at most 12,000 to buy back the share. A sure gain of at least 500.
  2. Down factor replaced by d = 1.06, above 1 + r = 1.05: borrow 10,000 at 5%, buy the share. At expiry: the share is worth at least 10,600, the debt 10,500. A sure gain of at least 100.

In the animation, pick a node to see Δ and the deposit. Change the up move, the down move and the rate: the price changes, and no probability is asked for.

Binomial tree of a European callq = 0.6250

In each box: the price on top, the option value below. Green: up move; red: down move. Choose a box to see its replicating portfolio.

Option price

1,190.4762

Delta (period 0)

0.5000

units of the underlying to hold

Lending

−3,809.5238

borrowed; Δ × S + B = 1,190.4762

Two states of the world is unrealistic; the tree becomes useful when many short periods are chained together. The BVMAC does not list options, for that matter: no compartment of its list is devoted to forward contracts (BVMAC, products and services).

From memory: write Δ and the price of an option over one period, then say why the probability of a rise is not in them.

Your turn

A share at 100 will go to 130 or 90. A call with a strike of 100 has a Δ of...

1A share at 100 will go to 130 or 90. A call with a strike of 100 has a Δ of...

Same share, rate of 5%: the deposit in the portfolio that replicates this call is...

2Same share, rate of 5%: the deposit in the portfolio that replicates this call is...

If all investors think a rise is more likely, the call price (share price unchanged)...

3If all investors think a rise is more likely, the call price (share price unchanged)...

With u = 1.2 and d = 0.8, which rate per period creates an arbitrage without even using an option?

4With u = 1.2 and d = 0.8, which rate per period creates an arbitrage without even using an option?

Read next: MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401 Finance Theory I, Recitation 5 « Options » (2008)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further