Credit ratings, an opinion on a scale
Agencies, scales and the BBB−/BB+ line between investment grade and speculative grade.
Lesson 88 min
By the end of this lesson
- Place a rating on either side of the BBB−/BB+ line
- Count the notches between two ratings on the same scale
- Explain what a rating measures and what it does not guarantee
In this lesson4
Before lending, you want to know whether you will be repaid. Specialist agencies sum this question up in a rating: AAA, BBB, B, CCC… What you will take from this lesson: reading a rating, placing it on either side of the line between "investment grade" and "speculative grade", and knowing what it does not guarantee.
An opinion, not a guarantee
The COSUMAF General Regulation defines a rating as an "opinion issued by a specialised agency, licensed by the market regulator, assessing the financial solvency of an issuer or of a transaction"; it is issued "by applying a well-defined classification system providing for different rating categories" (definitions and article 662 of the 2023 COSUMAF General Regulation). European law says the same: "an opinion regarding the creditworthiness" (ESMA).
Credit rating
A licensed agency's opinion on an issuer's ability to pay its debts on time, expressed on a scale of letters.
The key word is "opinion": an agency can be wrong, and a rating can change.
Who rates, under whose supervision
In the CEMAC, to operate on the regional market a rating agency must be licensed by the COSUMAF and have, among other things, its registered office in a member State (article 653). It must prevent conflicts of interest (article 663) and publish its methods and main assumptions (article 668). In the European Union, ESMA registers and supervises agencies, including the European subsidiaries of Moody's, S&P Global and Fitch.
The issuer asks for a rating
The fictional company Baobab wants to borrow. It hires a rating agency and opens its books: debts, revenue, plans.
The scale and its line
The S&P and Fitch scales run from AAA, the best, to D, default; Moody's from Aaa to C. Notches refine each category: "+" and "−" at S&P and Fitch (BBB+, BBB, BBB−), figures 1, 2, 3 at Moody's (Baa1, Baa2, Baa3).
The line that matters: according to the US regulator FINRA, a bond rated below Baa3 by Moody's or below BBB− by S&P and Fitch is speculative grade, known as "high yield"; such bonds offer higher rates "to attract investors and compensate for the higher level of risk", and their default risk is generally higher (FINRA, high-yield bonds).
Investment grade
Ratings from AAA to BBB− (Aaa to Baa3 at Moody's): the issuers the agency judges safest.
Speculative grade
Ratings from BB+ (Ba1 at Moody's) downwards: a higher default risk, paid for with a higher rate.
The agencies' definition pages could be read only in extract (access blocked to robots): only the letters and the line, confirmed by FINRA, are given here. This section quotes no current rating of any CEMAC State: they have not been checked with the agencies.
A bond is rated BB+. Is it investment grade or speculative? And a bond rated Baa3?
Ranking five fictional borrowersFictional
Five fictional issuers and their ratings: Kalao A−, Baobab plc BBB+, Iroko plc BB, Néré plc BBB−, State of Mbanza CCC+.
- From safest to least safe: Kalao (A−), Baobab (BBB+), Néré (BBB−), Iroko (BB), Mbanza (CCC+).
- Investment grade: Kalao, Baobab, Néré. Speculative: Iroko, Mbanza.
- Néré is on the edge: a single downgrade, from BBB− to BB+, would push it into speculative grade.
- Counting notches: from BBB+ to BB+, Baobab would lose 3 notches (BBB+ → BBB → BBB− → BB+).
- What the rating does not say: neither the bond's price, nor its yield, nor how easy it is to sell. A rating does not replace reading the information document.
From memory: give the COSUMAF definition of a rating in one sentence, and the lowest investment-grade rating at S&P.
Key points
- A rating is an opinion on the ability to pay on time, not a guarantee.
- In the CEMAC, agencies are licensed by the COSUMAF; in the EU, supervised by ESMA.
- The line: BBB−/Baa3 and above, investment grade; BB+/Ba1 and below, speculative.
- The lesson on sovereign ratings applies these ratings to States; the one on the credit spread shows what a downgrade does to a bond's price.
Your turn
Read next: Règlement général de la COSUMAF du 23 mai 2023
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.