Risk-neutral probability and multi-period trees
A discounted expected value under q, node by node from expiry: European and American options, and the bridge to Black-Scholes.
Lesson 710 min
By the end of this lesson
- Calculate the risk-neutral probability and an option’s value as a discounted expected value
- Value a European or American option by working backwards over several periods
- Explain how the tree price converges to Black-Scholes as the periods multiply
In this lesson4
Replication gives the price of an option over one period, but solving for Δ and the deposit at every node of a large tree is tedious. A shortcut gives the same number: act as if the world were risk-neutral, compute an expected value and discount it. What you will learn: value an option, European or American, in a multi-period tree by working backwards.
A probability that is not one
In a tree where the price is multiplied by or by each period, with a risk-free rate per period:
Risk-neutral probability
The number q between 0 and 1 that makes the underlying earn exactly the risk-free rate on average: q = (1 + r − d) ÷ (u − d). An option's value is the expected value of its future values, computed with q, discounted at the risk-free rate.
Writing and for the option's values after a rise and after a fall, and for its value one period earlier:
Cox, Ross and Rubinstein show that this number is the probability of a rise that would prevail if investors were risk-neutral, and that the call's value can be read as the expected value of its discounted future value in that world (Cox, Ross and Rubinstein, 1979, section 3). The MIT 15.401 course finds the same price both ways, by replication and with q (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, Recitation 5).
In plain wordsSetting the scales first
Before weighing, the stallholder sets her scales with a weight she knows. Risk-neutral odds are set the same way: they are chosen so that the share, whose price is known, earns on average neither more nor less than risk-free savings. Once the scales are set, the option is weighed: take the average of what it will pay with those odds, bring it back to today, and you find exactly the price of the copy. These are not the real odds of a rise: they are a setting for the calculation, not a forecast.
The fictional call from the previous lessonFictional
Share at 10,000 XAF, u = 1.2, d = 0.8, rate 5%, call with a strike of 10,000 worth 2,000 or 0.
- Risk-neutral probability: q = (1.05 − 0.8) ÷ (1.2 − 0.8) = 0.25 ÷ 0.4 = 0.625.
- Check: 0.625 × 12,000 + 0.375 × 8,000 = 7,500 + 3,000 = 10,500 = 10,000 × 1.05. Under q, the share does earn 5% on average.
- Call value: (0.625 × 2,000 + 0.375 × 0) ÷ 1.05 = 1,250 ÷ 1.05 = 1,190.48 XAF, the price found by replication.
q is not the real probability of a rise, which nobody needed to estimate. It is a calculation tool: it packs into a single number the information that replication drew from the share and the deposit.
Why must the share price, weighted by q and 1 − q, earn exactly the risk-free rate?
Working back through the tree
Over several periods, you start from expiry, where the option's value is known, and apply the formula node by node back to today.
European put, 3 periodsFictional
Share at 10,000 XAF, u = 1.2, d = 0.8, rate 5% per period, q = 0.625, put with a strike of 10,000.
- Expiry: prices 17,280, 11,520, 7,680 and 5,120. The put is worth 0, 0, 2,320 and 4,880.
- Period 2: at 14,400, it is worth 0. At 9,600: (0.625 × 0 + 0.375 × 2,320) ÷ 1.05 = 870 ÷ 1.05 = 828.57. At 6,400: (0.625 × 2,320 + 0.375 × 4,880) ÷ 1.05 = (1,450 + 1,830) ÷ 1.05 = 3,123.81.
- Period 1: at 12,000: (0.625 × 0 + 0.375 × 828.571) ÷ 1.05 = 310.714 ÷ 1.05 = 295.92. At 8,000: (0.625 × 828.571 + 0.375 × 3,123.810) ÷ 1.05 = (517.857 + 1,171.429) ÷ 1.05 = 1,608.84.
- Today: (0.625 × 295.92 + 0.375 × 1,608.84) ÷ 1.05 = (184.95 + 603.32) ÷ 1.05 = 750.73 XAF.
American option: exercising early
European option
An option that can be exercised only on its expiry date.
American option
An option that can be exercised at any time up to and including its expiry date.
These are the definitions in the CFTC glossary (CFTC) and, under the names European and American exercise, in Cboe's (Cboe). In the tree, an American option is worth, at each node, the larger of two amounts: immediate exercise or holding on (the discounted expected value).
The same put, AmericanFictional
- At 6,400: exercising pays 10,000 − 6,400 = 3,600, holding is worth 3,123.81. You exercise: the node is worth 3,600.
- At 9,600: exercising pays 400, holding is worth 828.57. You hold.
- At 8,000: holding is worth (0.625 × 828.57 + 0.375 × 3,600) ÷ 1.05 = (517.86 + 1,350) ÷ 1.05 = 1,778.91; exercising pays 2,000. You exercise.
- At 12,000: 295.92, as for the European put.
- Today: (0.625 × 295.92 + 0.375 × 2,000) ÷ 1.05 = (184.95 + 750) ÷ 1.05 = 890.43 XAF, that is 139.70 more than the European put.
Exercising a put early means collecting the strike price sooner and investing it. Cox, Ross and Rubinstein show that there is always a price below which the American put should be exercised immediately, and that early exercise becomes more likely when the put is deep in the money and the rate is high. For a call without dividends, by contrast, the holding value always exceeds the immediate gain when the rate is positive: exercising early is pointless (Cox, Ross and Rubinstein, sections 3 and 5).
In the animation, early-exercise nodes are marked. Switch between European and American, then raise the rate: more nodes move to exercise.
In each box: the price on top, the option value below. Green: up move; red: down move. Choose a box to see its replicating portfolio. In coral: exercising now is worth more than holding.
Option price
890.4276
Delta (period 0)
−0.4260
units of the underlying to hold
Lending
5,150.6317
lent; Δ × S + B = 890.4276
From the tree to Black-Scholes
For an annual volatility and a length of time in years cut into periods of length , Cox, Ross and Rubinstein choose:
Their model contains Black and Scholes's as a limiting case when the number of periods tends to infinity; in their examples, the gap is at most $0.25 at 5 periods, $0.07 at 20 periods, and nil to the cent at 150 periods (Cox, Ross and Rubinstein, section 5).
A fictional call cut ever more finelyFictional
Price 100, strike 100, σ = 20%, one year, continuous rate 5% (that is e^(0.05 ÷ n) − 1 per period). For n = 1: u = e^0.2 = 1.2214. For n = 3: u = e^(0.2 × √(1/3)) = 1.1224.
| Periods n | 1 | 2 | 3 | 5 | 10 | 50 | 100 | 500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Call price | 12.16 | 9.54 | 11.04 | 10.81 | 10.25 | 10.41 | 10.43 | 10.45 |
The Black-Scholes formula gives 10.45. The tree price oscillates around this value and gets closer as n increases.
From memory: how do you value an American put in a three-period tree?
Your turn
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.