Skip to content
Criée

Spotting a scam before you pay

“Certain” gains, fake official notices, pyramids and fake crypto-assets: the signs, the sum that unmasks them and the checks.

Lesson 78 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Spot the signs of a scam in an offer or a message
  • Work out how many new members a pyramid must recruit to keep its promises
  • Name the checks to make before handing over your money
In this lesson3

"Put in 50,000, get double back in a month." A friend believes it, he has already received his first gains, and he invites you in. Scams never present themselves as scams: they look like a good deal, an official message or a favour. What this lesson teaches: spotting the signs of a scam, showing with numbers why a pyramid always ends up collapsing, and knowing what to check before you hand over your money.

The signs that keep coming back

The AMF, the French regulator, puts it bluntly: "There is no miracle investment! A high return can never be guaranteed." It advises fleeing urgency ("a good deal today will still be one tomorrow") and being wary of a stranger, even one recommended by someone close (AMF, "Éviter les arnaques"). Authorities in the region have already warned about these same signs:

  • a "certain" gain: the COSUMAF warned against an outfit in Douala inviting the public to buy its shares with promises of "certain gains" over 1, 2 and 3 years, without a licence; it points out that placing securities with the public requires a prior licence, and that you must check the regulator's approval and the involvement of a licensed brokerage firm (COSUMAF statement);
  • a fake official notice: in 2025, the BEAC denounced a fake call for tenders of 100 billion FCFA spread on social media in its name, and pointed out that it "does not finance any national or sub-regional project in return for a financial contribution"; it invites people to check its official website (BEAC statement);
  • paying to receive: a "prize" that first requires fees, as in the mobile money frauds of lesson 4;
  • miracle crypto-assets: European authorities point out that many crypto-assets are highly risky and speculative, that you can lose your whole stake, and that you should be wary of social media adverts promising quick gains (ESMA, EBA, EIOPA, 2022); the lesson "Crypto-assets: a price with no issuer who pays" and the lesson "Retail forex: leverage and scams" go into detail.

From memory: what had the outfit targeted by the COSUMAF promised, and what was missing to make its offer legal?

Why a pyramid collapses

Ponzi scheme

A fraud that pays earlier participants "gains" taken from the money of newer ones, until the inflows are no longer enough.

According to the SEC, the US regulator, a pyramid promises high returns with little risk, needs a constant flow of new money and collapses when recruitment slows or when many people want to withdraw at once (Investor.gov, "Ponzi Scheme").

The fictional club that promises 20% a monthFictional

100 members each pay in 50,000 FCFA: the fund receives 100 × 50,000 = 5,000,000 FCFA. The club has no real activity.

  1. The first month. Each member must be paid 20%: 5,000,000 × 20% = 1,000,000 FCFA. To pay without touching the fund, it needs 1,000,000 ÷ 50,000 = 20 new members.
  2. The second month. 120 members, so 1,200,000 FCFA to pay out: 24 new members. Membership must grow by 20% every month.
  3. After one year. 100 × 1.2¹² ≈ 892 members. After two years: about 7,950. After three years: about 70,900.
  4. The end. A neighbourhood, then a town, are no longer enough. When new members run out, the "gains" stop and most members lose their stake; the first ones were paid with the money of the last.

Writing N0N_0 for the number of members at the start, gg for the promised monthly return and NmN_m for the number of members needed after mm months:

Nm=N0×(1+g)mN_m = N_0 \times (1 + g)^m

The lesson "Scams: when a gain is guaranteed" does the same sum for an investment promised at 10% a month.

The first gains received, the ones that reassure your friend, prove nothing: in a pyramid, they are paid with the money of those who join after him. Recruiting people close to you to "get your stake back" means making them lose.

Reflexes before you hand over your money

  1. Nobody guarantees a high return. The bigger the promise, the more suspicious.
  2. Check the authorisation. A public offer of securities needs the COSUMAF's approval in the CEMAC (see the lesson "The COSUMAF: license, inspect, sanction"); a credit, microfinance or payment institution needs a licence supervised by the COBAC (see lesson 5).
  3. Check at the source. A statement "from the BEAC" or "from the COSUMAF" is checked on their official website, not on a screenshot.
  4. Refuse urgency. A good deal will still be one tomorrow.
  5. Never pay to receive a prize, and never give your code.
  6. Talk about it first. To a trusted adult, to your bank, to the regulator. Afterwards, the AMF reminds us that in the event of fraud, you must file a complaint.

Identity theft

Passing yourself off as another person or an organisation (operator, bank, authority) in order to obtain money or information.

Without looking back: a club promises 10% a month and has 200 members. How many new members does it need in the first month if everyone pays the same stake?

Your turn

Which of these messages is the clearest sign of a scam?

1Which of these messages is the clearest sign of a scam?

Club of 50 members, stake of 20,000 FCFA, 20% promised a month. New members needed in the first month?

2Club of 50 members, stake of 20,000 FCFA, 20% promised a month. New members needed in the first month?

A message 'from the BEAC' offers to finance your project in return for a contribution. According to the BEAC, it is...

3A message 'from the BEAC' offers to finance your project in return for a contribution. According to the BEAC, it is...

Before subscribing to an investment offered to the public in the CEMAC, you check...

4Before subscribing to an investment offered to the public in the CEMAC, you check...

Read next: COSUMAF, alerte sur un appel public à l’épargne illégal

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further