Borrowing without being trapped: monthly payment and APR
Work out a monthly payment, compare two loans by their annual percentage rate and check what your income can carry.
Lesson 69 min
By the end of this lesson
- Work out the monthly payment on a loan repaid in equal instalments
- Compare two loans by their annual percentage rate rather than their advertised rate
- Work out the debt-to-income ratio and what is left in the budget
A phone for work, a sewing machine, a motorbike: borrowing can help you get started. But a loan you do not fully understand can also cost far more than planned, or weigh on a budget for years. What this lesson teaches: working out a monthly payment, comparing two loans by their annual percentage rate, and checking what share of your income the repayments will take.
The monthly payment
A consumer loan is usually repaid in equal monthly payments: the same amount every month, made up of interest and a share of the capital. It is the monthly version of the level annuities in the lesson "Repaying: repayment schedule and debt service".
Monthly payment
The sum paid every month to repay a loan; it contains the month's interest and a share of the capital borrowed.
Writing for the capital borrowed, for the monthly interest rate, for the number of months and for the monthly payment:
Yannick borrows 300,000 FCFA over 12 months (fictional offer A)Fictional
Rate: 1.5% a month, a nominal rate of 12 × 1.5% = 18% a year. Arrangement fee: 15,000 FCFA, paid at the start.
- .
- .
- .
- .
- FCFA a month.
Total repaid: 12 × 27,504 = 330,048 FCFA, of which 30,048 FCFA is interest. With the arrangement fee, the loan costs 30,048 + 15,000 = 45,048 FCFA.
From memory: why does the total repaid exceed the capital borrowed, and what is each monthly payment made of?
The annual percentage rate
The advertised rate does not tell the whole story: arrangement, insurance or guarantee fees come on top. In the CEMAC, the annual percentage rate (TEG, taux effectif global) includes them. BEAC Governor's instruction no. 004/2021 defines it as an annual rate which ensures, "using the compound interest method", equality between the sums lent and all the borrower's payments, "in capital, interest and all fees and charges known on the date the credit agreement is concluded"; it is calculated to two decimal places (BEAC, instruction no. 004/2021). It applies CEMAC regulation no. 04/19 of 10 August 2020 on the TEG, usury and the publication of banking conditions.
Annual percentage rate
The total cost of a loan expressed as a yearly rate: it counts the interest and all fees known at signing (arrangement, insurance, guarantee). In the CEMAC it is called the TEG.
Two offers for the same 300,000 FCFA over 12 months (fictional offers)Fictional
- Offer A: 1.5% a month and 15,000 FCFA in fees. Yannick actually receives 300,000 − 15,000 = 285,000 FCFA, and repays 12 × 27,504 FCFA. The yearly rate that makes the two equal, worked out with a spreadsheet: TEG ≈ 31.89%, whereas the nominal rate is only 18%.
- Offer B: 1.7% a month, no fees. Monthly payment ≈ 27,848 FCFA; total 12 × 27,848 = 334,176 FCFA. With no fees, the TEG is %.
- The total paid. A: 330,048 + 15,000 = 345,048 FCFA. B: 334,176 FCFA. Offer B, with the higher advertised rate, costs 10,872 FCFA less.
So to compare two loans, you compare their TEGs, not their advertised rates. Fees weigh all the more when the loan is short.
Usury rate
The maximum rate that a loan's TEG must not exceed; above it, the loan is usurious and forbidden.
According to the legal press, regulation no. 04/19 provides that a loan is usurious if its TEG exceeds the usury rate set each quarter by the BEAC's Monetary Policy Committee (Droit Médias Finance). The text of the regulation and the current usury rates were not read for this lesson: ask for the TEG in writing, and compare it.
What your income can carry
The US consumer protection authority (CFPB) measures the weight of debt with a ratio: all monthly debt payments divided by gross monthly income; with 2,000 dollars of payments for 6,000 dollars of income, it is 33% (CFPB, "What is a debt-to-income ratio?"). The CFPB adds that the accepted limit varies between lenders and loans.
Debt-to-income ratio
The share of monthly income taken by all loan payments.
Writing for the sum of all your monthly payments and for your monthly income:
Can Yannick take offer B?Fictional
Yannick earns 150,000 FCFA a month and already repays 10,000 FCFA a month for another purchase.
- Total monthly payments. 27,848 + 10,000 = 37,848 FCFA.
- Debt-to-income ratio. 37,848 ÷ 150,000 ≈ 25%.
- What is left. 150,000 − 37,848 = 112,152 FCFA for his fixed and variable expenses and his savings: he redoes his budget with this figure before signing.
No CEMAC rule setting a ceiling on the debt-to-income ratio for individuals was found for this lesson. The right test is still the budget: after the monthly payment, fixed expenses and a little saving must still fit.
Without looking back: two loans have the same advertised rate, but one has a 20,000 FCFA arrangement fee. Which has the higher TEG, and why?
Your turn
Read next: BEAC, instruction du Gouverneur n°004/2021 sur le taux effectif global
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.