Valuing with comparables
Apply the P/E and enterprise value multiple of similar companies, take off the debt, and get a range.
Lesson 59 min
By the end of this lesson
- Value equity with the PER of comparable companies
- Go from enterprise value to the value for shareholders
- Choose the right multiple for a loss-making company
In this lesson4
To estimate the price of a house, you look at what similar houses nearby sold for. Analysts do the same with companies: they take a multiple observed at comparable companies and apply it to the company being studied. What this lesson teaches: valuing a company with two multiples, the P/E ratio and enterprise value to EBITDA, and drawing a range from them.
The Investing section introduced the P/E ratio and dividend yield (Valuing a company: profit, P/E, dividend). Here they are used to set a value, with an added multiple that takes debt into account.
The comparables principle
The OpenStax textbook separates two ways of applying a multiple: analysing listed comparable companies and analysing precedent transactions, that is, the prices paid in recent takeovers (OpenStax, 11.1). The method takes three moves:
- choose companies in the same business, of similar size and growth;
- calculate their multiple (share price ÷ earnings per share, for example);
- apply that multiple to the matching figure for the company being studied.
Valuation multiple
The ratio between a company's value and one of its figures (profit, sales, earnings before depreciation), observed at comparable companies and then applied to the one being valued.
Two multiples, two families
- The P/E ratio sets the value of the shares against net profit. It gives a value for shareholders directly: equity value = net profit × P/E.
- Enterprise value to EBITDA sets the value of the whole business, shareholders and lenders together, against what operations generate before depreciation, interest and tax. OpenStax describes it as "a commonly used metric to compare the relative values of different businesses" (OpenStax, 11.1). To get back to shareholders, you take off net debt.
Enterprise value
The value of the whole business, for everyone who finances it: equity value plus net debt (financial debts minus cash).
Writing for the value of equity, for net profit, for enterprise value and for net debt:
Why two families? Because two companies in the same business can be financed differently. The P/E mixes the quality of the business with the weight of interest; enterprise value to EBITDA compares businesses before looking at debt.
There are others. The price to book multiple (share price ÷ equity per share) works poorly for companies rich in patents or brands, which barely show on the balance sheet; the price to sales multiple is used for loss-making companies (OpenStax, 11.1).
From memory: why do you take off net debt after applying an enterprise value multiple, but not after a P/E?
The life of a valuation
Okoumé, a fictional unlisted company, is thinking of going public. An analyst works out what its shares are worth.
Okoumé’s accounts
Net profit 70 M FCFA, earnings before depreciation, interest and tax 180 M FCFA, net debt 300 M FCFA. What is the company worth?
Valuing Okoumé step by stepFictional
Fictional accounts, in millions of FCFA: net profit 70; earnings before depreciation, interest and tax 180; net debt 300; 1,000,000 shares.
- Peers' P/E ratios: 10, 12 and 14. Equity value: 70 × 10 = 700; 70 × 12 = 840; 70 × 14 = 980.
- Enterprise value multiples of the same peers: 6, 7 and 8 times. Enterprise value: 180 × 6 = 1,080; 180 × 7 = 1,260; 180 × 8 = 1,440.
- Take off net debt: 1,080 − 300 = 780; 1,260 − 300 = 960; 1,440 − 300 = 1,140.
- Per share: from 700,000,000 ÷ 1,000,000 = 700 FCFA to 1,140,000,000 ÷ 1,000,000 = 1,140 FCFA.
- Central value: with the middle multiples, 840 and 960 M, i.e. 840 to 960 FCFA per share.
The company is not "worth" one figure: it is worth a range, which depends on the peers chosen.
The limits
- Choosing the peers means choosing the result. Adding a very expensive company to the basket lifts the whole range.
- A multiple is a snapshot. OpenStax points out that it captures a company at one moment and does not show its path; a P/E on its own "will actually tell an analyst very little" (OpenStax, 11.1).
- If the whole market is expensive, so are the peers. During a bubble, the method follows the bubble (A bubble inflates, then bursts).
- Few peers in the CEMAC. The BVMAC list has few companies per sector; analysts often have to use peers from other exchanges, listed in other currencies and under other conditions.
A valuation is neither a guaranteed price nor a buy recommendation. The listing or exchange price is set by supply and demand, under COSUMAF oversight. The exact number of listed companies per sector on the BVMAC has not been checked for this lesson.
Without looking back: earnings before depreciation, interest and tax 50, multiple 8, net debt 120, 200,000 shares. What is one share worth?
Your turn
Read next: OpenStax, Principles of Finance, 11.1 « Multiple Approaches to Stock Valuation »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.