Skip to content
Criée

Complaining: from the broker to the mediator

A free complaint, then free COSUMAF mediation: deadlines, evidence and limits.

Lesson 87 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Complain in the right order, to the intermediary and then to COSUMAF
  • Calculate the loss caused by a badly executed order
  • Spot a suspicious investment offer before having to complain
In this lesson4

An order executed wrongly, fees not announced, a statement that does not match: the aggrieved saver is not alone. CEMAC texts open a two-step path, first with the intermediary, then with the COSUMAF. What this lesson teaches: complaining in the right order, with the right evidence, and knowing what mediation can and cannot do.

Step one: the complaint to the intermediary

Every market intermediary must have a written, transparent complaints-handling policy approved by its management, deal with complaints promptly and keep a register of complaints received and action taken. It gives the identity and contact details of the person in charge of complaints, and lets clients file a complaint “free of charge” (COSUMAF GR 2023, art. 280). The compliance officer oversees this process.

Complaint

The written request by which a client reports a problem to their intermediary and asks for it to be put right. It is free and entered in the complaints register.

Step two: COSUMAF mediation

The COSUMAF receives complaints from any interested person or any association defending holders, examines them, and may propose an amicable settlement: a member of its Board is then appointed mediator (Regulation No. 01/22, art. 37). The General Regulation sets the rules (COSUMAF GR 2023, arts. 80 to 88):

  • referral suspends the limitation period for civil and administrative action;
  • the parties may be assisted by the adviser of their choice;
  • the opinion is given within 60 days of receiving all the elements of the file, a deadline that can be extended if the case is complex;
  • the mediator and the parties are bound by confidentiality;
  • the opinion is reasoned but “is not binding on the parties”; if they agree, the mediator ensures the settlement is carried out;
  • mediation is free.

Mediation

A free procedure in which a neutral third party proposes an amicable solution to a dispute; the proposal does not bind the parties.

From memory: in which order should Awa act, and what does each step cost?

The life of a complaint

The life of a complaint1/6

An abnormal execution

Awa had placed an order to buy 40 shares with a limit of 9,500. Her statement shows 40 shares paid 9,800: the order was keyed in at market by mistake. Difference: 12,000 FCFA.

Putting a figure on the loss before complaining, step by stepFictional

Awa had placed an order to buy 40 shares with a limit of 9,500 FCFA; it was keyed in at market and executed at 9,800.

  1. The most she should have paid: 40 × 9,500 = 380,000 FCFA.
  2. What she paid: 40 × 9,800 = 392,000 FCFA.
  3. Loss: 392,000 − 380,000 = 12,000 FCFA, i.e. 40 × 300.
  4. Evidence to attach: the written order with the limit, the execution notice or statement, the brokerage firm's reply. A loss that is quantified and proven can be discussed; an impression cannot.

Elsewhere, the logic is the same. In France, the AMF ombudsman is “a free public service”, approached after a prior complaint to the professional (AMF, “Le médiateur”).

Protecting yourself before you need to complain

The best complaint is the one you never have to make. Three habits, drawn from the texts:

  • check the licence of the intermediary with the COSUMAF, which keeps the list of licences; a licensed firm must show its licence references in its documents (COSUMAF GR 2023, art. 249);
  • turn down an offer with no approved document: a public offering without an information document approved by the COSUMAF carries a penalty of at least 25,000,000 FCFA, and the COSUMAF may freeze accounts or seize the sums (Regulation No. 01/22, art. 264);
  • keep a written record of every order and every exchange.

A Central African financial market guarantee fund (FOGAMAF) is established by Regulation No. 01/22, art. 248, but its compensation ceiling and conditions were not read: do not count on any guaranteed amount without checking with the COSUMAF. To review who protects savings in the CEMAC, see the lesson “Who protects your savings” in the high-school track.

Without looking back: does the COSUMAF mediator's opinion oblige the brokerage firm to pay?

Your turn

A client wants to file a complaint with their brokerage firm. How much does it cost?

1A client wants to file a complaint with their brokerage firm. How much does it cost?

Order for 25 shares limited at 8,000, executed at 8,400. The loss is...

2Order for 25 shares limited at 8,000, executed at 8,400. The loss is...

What happens to the limitation period when the COSUMAF is approached?

3What happens to the limitation period when the COSUMAF is approached?

Within what time does the COSUMAF mediator give an opinion?

4Within what time does the COSUMAF mediator give an opinion?

An investment offer arrives with no document approved by the COSUMAF. It is...

5An investment offer arrives with no document approved by the COSUMAF. It is...

Read next: Règlement général de la COSUMAF du 23 mai 2023

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further