Ethics: the client’s interest first
A front-run order costed by the engine, managing conflicts of interest and the CFA Institute standards.
Lesson 98 min
By the end of this lesson
- Apply the primacy of the client’s interest to a front-run order
- Calculate the extra cost for a client whose order is front-run
- Spot a conflict of interest and say how it is managed
A market professional sees orders, plans and information that their clients do not see. Ethics is the rule of conduct that stops them using it against those clients. What this lesson teaches: applying the principle that the client's interest comes first to a concrete case, and spotting a conflict of interest.
The principle
In the CEMAC, shareholders, managers and staff of market intermediaries must “in all circumstances” respect “the principle of the primacy of clients' interests” and refrain from any initiative that would favour their own interests to the detriment of their clients' (COSUMAF GR 2023, art. 284).
Client's interest first
The rule that an intermediary and its staff put the client's interest before their own, and never profit from a situation at the client's expense.
A front-run order
Compare two ways of behaving when faced with the same large order from a client. The trades are computed by the portal's matching engine, on the same book.
A large order
Grâce, a client, wants 80 shares of the fictional company Kapok at market. The book is thin: her order will push the price up.
What a front-run order costs, step by stepFictional
The book offers 30 shares at 10,000, 30 at 10,050, 40 at 10,100 and 50 at 10,200. Grâce buys 80 shares at market.
- Handled fairly: 30 × 10,000 + 30 × 10,050 + 20 × 10,100 = 300,000 + 301,500 + 202,000 = 803,500 FCFA, about 10,044 per share.
- Front-run: Hervé first buys 30 shares at 10,000 for himself. Grâce gets 30 × 10,050 + 40 × 10,100 + 10 × 10,200 = 301,500 + 404,000 + 102,000 = 807,500 FCFA, about 10,094 per share.
- Extra cost for Grâce: 807,500 − 803,500 = 4,000 FCFA.
- Hervé's paper gain: his 30 shares bought at 10,000 are worth 10,200 at the last price, i.e. 30 × 200 = 6,000 FCFA, obtained thanks to information about his client.
The CEMAC texts read do not name this practice (“front running”); it is presented here as contrary to the principle of the primacy of clients' interests in article 284, which is an inference, not a quotation. Information about a client's order may also fall under the confidentiality that the compliance officer oversees.
From memory: in the example, where does Hervé's gain come from?
Conflicts of interest
A conflict of interest is not a breach in itself: it is a situation where the interest of the intermediary, an employee or another client may run against a client's. The breach is failing to manage it. Every intermediary must (COSUMAF GR 2023, arts. 281 to 283):
- set out in writing a conflict-of-interest policy suited to its size and activities;
- identify risky situations and the procedures to prevent or manage them;
- keep a register of conflicts that have arisen or may arise, and report on it in writing to its management at least once a year.
Conflict of interest
A situation where the interest of an intermediary, its staff or another client may run against a client's.
Two further requirements complete the picture: the people serving clients must have the necessary knowledge and skills, and the intermediary must be able to show this to the COSUMAF (art. 285); the compliance officer prevents confidential information from circulating and informs staff of the sanctions attached to inside information.
A global reference for students
The CFA Institute code of ethics, which many finance students prepare for, organises its rules into seven standards: professionalism; integrity of capital markets; duties to clients; duties to employers; investment analysis, recommendations and actions; conflicts of interest; responsibilities as a member or candidate (CFA Institute, Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct). The first two overlap with this whole section: do not manipulate, do not use inside information, serve the client first.
Without looking back: is a conflict of interest a breach? What must the intermediary do?
Your turn
Read next: Règlement général de la COSUMAF du 23 mai 2023
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.