The financial analyst and the research note
A price target is calculated, and the note that carries it follows precise independence rules.
Lesson 58 min
By the end of this lesson
- Calculate a price target and the upside that sets the recommendation
- State the independence rules that govern the analyst’s note
- Distinguish the sell-side analyst from the buy-side analyst
In this lesson3
A financial analyst reads a company's accounts, derives a value from them and publishes a view: buy, hold or sell. The product is a research note. Two things make a good note: an honest calculation, and rules that protect the view from those who would like to steer it. The skill in this lesson: working out a simple price target and citing the analyst's independence rules.
Financial analyst
The person who studies an issuer and publishes a recommendation (buy, hold, sell), often with a price target.
The COSUMAF general regulation calls "financial analyses or investment recommendations" the information that recommends or suggests an investment strategy (art. 322), and lists the financial analyst among the functions that require a professional card (art. 14) (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023). According to the CFA Institute, its charterholders typically work as research analysts or portfolio managers (CFA Institute, "Overview of the CFA Program").
Two houses, two analysts
The sell-side analyst works in a brokerage firm or a bank; their notes go out to clients. The buy-side analyst works in a management company; their research serves the manager and stays in-house. The calculation is the same; the rules on publication only concern the first.
The calculation: a price target
The simplest method multiplies earnings per share by a multiple judged reasonable, the P/E ratio. The Company and Investing sections explain where this multiple comes from; here we take it as the analyst's assumption.
Price target
The price an analyst considers justified for a share over a given horizon. It is an estimate, not a promise.
The note on KapokFictional
The fictional company Kapok reports earnings per share of 800 FCFA. Its share trades at 8,000 FCFA. The analyst uses a P/E of 12. Her fictional firm says "buy" above +10% upside, "sell" below −10%, "hold" in between.
- The target. 800 × 12 = 9,600 FCFA.
- The upside. (9,600 − 8,000) ÷ 8,000 = 0.20, i.e. +20%.
- The view. +20% exceeds +10%: "buy".
- Sensitivity. If expected earnings fall by 10%, to 720 FCFA: 720 × 12 = 8,640 FCFA, i.e. +8%. The view becomes "hold".
An assumption that moves by 10% changes the recommendation. An honest note writes down its assumptions so the reader can redo the calculation.
Writing for earnings per share, for the chosen P/E, for the price target, for the current price and for the upside:
From memory: earnings per share 500 FCFA, P/E used 14, price 6,000 FCFA. What target, what upside?
The rules: protecting the view
A recommendation that lifts a price is worth money: to the issuer, to the firm's trading desk, to the analyst herself. The COSUMAF general regulation closes these doors one by one (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, art. 321):
- the intermediary physically separates analysts from people whose interests may conflict with the note's readers, or sets up other information barriers;
- analysts do not make personal trades that go against their current recommendations;
- they accept no inducements from people with an interest in the subject of the note, and do not promise issuers favourable coverage;
- a draft note containing a recommendation or a price target may not be reviewed by the issuer, nor by anyone else, except to check compliance with legal obligations.
Information barrier
The physical or organisational separation that stops sensitive information passing from one team to another whose interests could profit from it.
Follow the note on Kapok, from published accounts to publication.
The accounts are published
Kapok, a fictional company, publishes its annual accounts: earnings of 800 FCFA per share. Everyone has access at the same moment.
An analyst's recommendation is neither a guarantee nor advice suited to your situation: the price target rests on assumptions that may prove wrong. Be especially wary of "recommendations" spread on forums and social media by people who hold the shares; the AMF urges caution towards opinions whose authors do not state their positions, and points out that "spreading false information is prohibited" (AMF, "Market surveillance"; see Market manipulation).
Without looking back: Kapok's finance director asks to read the note before it comes out, to 'check the figures'. What does compliance answer?
Your turn
Read next: Règlement général de la COSUMAF du 23 mai 2023
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.