The auction: bids ranked by rate
The Treasury serves the cheapest bids up to the amount offered: cut-off rate, weighted average rate, cover.
Lesson 39 min
By the end of this lesson
- Rank the bids at an auction and find the cut-off rate
- Work out the weighted average rate and the cover ratio
- Predict the effect of a larger amount offered on the cut-off rate
In this lesson4
When a CEMAC Treasury issues BTAs or OTAs, it does not set the rate itself: it puts an amount up for auction, and banks propose the rate at which they are willing to lend. What you will take from this lesson: ranking the bids at an auction, finding the cut-off rate and working out the weighted average rate.
An auction in reverse
In an ordinary auction the seller looks for the highest price. Here the State is borrowing: it looks for the lowest rate. At least three days before each auction, the BEAC sends the SVTs the type of security, its maturity, the issue amount and the deadlines (SVT specifications). Each SVT then submits one or more bids: an amount, a rate.
Auction (adjudication)
The sale of government securities by tender: bids are ranked from cheapest to dearest for the issuer, and served in that order up to the amount sought.
The four figures every result publishes:
- Cut-off rate (taux limite): the rate of the last bid accepted. Bids above it are rejected.
- Weighted average rate: the average rate of the accepted bids, each counting for the amount served.
- Total bids: the sum of all bids, accepted or not.
- Cover ratio: bids ÷ amount offered. Above 100%, demand exceeds the supply of securities.
Writing for the amount served to bid , for its rate, for total bids and for the amount offered, the weighted average rate and the cover ratio are:
Cut-off rate
The highest rate accepted at an auction, that of the last bid served.
Cover ratio
The ratio between the total amount of bids received and the amount put up for auction.
In plain wordsLenders made to compete
Imagine a trader who wants to borrow to fill her warehouse before the season. She gathers several lenders and asks each one: how much will you lend, and at what rate? She takes the cheapest lender first, then the next, and stops as soon as she has the sum she needs. The rate of the last lender accepted is the cut-off rate; the dearer ones leave with nothing. If the lenders offer far more money than she asked for, the cover is high: many people want to lend to her.
Bids are ranked by rate
- Banque Iroko6.00%Bid 3,000m
- Banque Moabi5.50%Bid 2,000m
- Banque Sapelli6.25%Bid 4,000m
- Banque Ébène5.75%Bid 3,000m
- Banque Okoumé5.90%Bid 1,500m
- Banque Padouk6.50%Bid 2,500m
The fictional Kalao Treasury announces 8,000m FCFA of 26-week bills. Six primary-dealer banks submit a bid before the deadline: an amount and a rate. Nobody sees the others' bids.
- Bid
- 16,000m
- Cover
- 200%
- Cut-off rate
- ?
- Weighted average
- ?
Change the amount offered: with 12,000 million instead of 8,000, more expensive bids must be reached, and the cut-off rate rises. A State with large needs pays more for its money.
Amount offered 8,000 million. Ranked bids: 2,000 at 5.50%, 3,000 at 5.75%, 1,500 at 5.90%, 3,000 at 6.00%. How much does the bank that bid 3,000 at 6.00% receive, and what is the cut-off rate?
A real result: Gabon, 23 March 2022
For 26-week BTAs, the Gabonese Treasury offered 9,500 million FCFA. Six of the eighteen SVTs in its network bid 16,105 million, at rates from 5.50% to 6.25%. Result: 9,500 million served, cut-off rate 5.95%, weighted average rate 5.7521%, cover 169.5% (results announcement).
Two readings: a cover of 169.5% says banks wanted to lend almost twice what was needed; bids between 5.95% and 6.25% were rejected. And the weighted average rate, below the cut-off rate, shows that the accepted bids were not all served at the same rate.
The text of Regulation no. 03/19 that sets the auction rules was not read. That each accepted bid is served at its own rate (a "multiple-rate" auction) is an inference, consistent with published results where the average rate is below the cut-off rate. The rule applied to bids exactly at the cut-off rate when they exceed the remaining amount (pro rata or otherwise) is not confirmed: the animation serves the first to arrive.
The animation's full calculationFictional
Fictional Kalao Treasury, 8,000 million offered. Six bids received (in millions): Iroko 3,000 at 6.00%; Moabi 2,000 at 5.50%; Sapelli 4,000 at 6.25%; Ébène 3,000 at 5.75%; Okoumé 1,500 at 5.90%; Padouk 2,500 at 6.50%.
- Bids: 3,000 + 2,000 + 4,000 + 3,000 + 1,500 + 2,500 = 16,000. Cover: 16,000 ÷ 8,000 = 200%.
- Ranking by rising rate: Moabi 5.50; Ébène 5.75; Okoumé 5.90; Iroko 6.00; Sapelli 6.25; Padouk 6.50.
- Serving: Moabi 2,000 (total 2,000), Ébène 3,000 (5,000), Okoumé 1,500 (6,500), Iroko 1,500 of 3,000 (8,000). Sapelli and Padouk are rejected.
- Cut-off rate: 6.00%, Iroko's.
- Weighted average rate: (2,000 × 5.50 + 3,000 × 5.75 + 1,500 × 5.90 + 1,500 × 6.00) ÷ 8,000 = (11,000 + 17,250 + 8,850 + 9,000) ÷ 8,000 = 46,100 ÷ 8,000 ≈ 5.76%.
- Annual cost for Kalao, simply: 8,000 × 5.76% ≈ 461 million, against 480 million if everything had been paid at the cut-off rate.
Another route: syndication
A Treasury can also issue by domestic syndication: it picks a lead manager and a group of SVTs, and negotiates with them the amount, the rate and the issue price of the OTAs; an auction can then top up the line (BEAC instruction no. 02 of 2021). The price then comes from a negotiation, not from a ranking of bids.
From memory: in what order are the bids at a government securities auction served, and why is the weighted average rate at most equal to the cut-off rate?
Your turn
Read next: BEAC, cahier des charges des spécialistes en valeurs du Trésor
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.