Skip to content
Criée

Risk, return and baskets of eggs

What can earn more can lose more. Spreading your money reduces the risk.

Lesson 98 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain why a riskier investment has to promise more
  • Work out what is left when one investment in a basket falls
  • Tell real diversification from several bets on the same thing
In this lesson4

A motorbike taxi driver lends money to two people. The first is his brother, who has a steady job and has always paid back. The second is a stranger who has just opened a shop. Which one will he ask for more in return for his loan? The stranger, of course: there is a greater chance he will never see his money again.

More risk, more return

What an investment earns is called its return. The danger of earning less than expected, or even losing, is called risk.

The two go together. The French markets authority (AMF) writes about bonds that the higher the risk, the bigger the payment (AMF guide to bonds). A fragile borrower has to promise a big coupon, otherwise nobody lends to it.

Two borrowersFictional

A large, solid company borrows 100,000 FCFA and offers a coupon of 5,000 FCFA a year.

A small, brand-new company borrows 100,000 FCFA and offers a coupon of 12,000 FCFA a year.

The second pays more, because it is more likely to be unable to pay back.

Return

What an investment earns: coupons, dividends, a rise in price.

Risk

The danger that an investment earns less than expected, or loses money.

Don't put all your eggs in one basket

Since any investment can go wrong, the AMF recommends diversifying your investments to reduce the overall risk (same guide). The proverb already says it: if all your eggs are in one basket and that basket falls, you lose everything.

Choose a number of baskets, then drop a basket.

12 eggs, how many baskets?

Spread your 12 eggs across

1 basket, 12 eggs in each.

Diversification

Spreading your money across several different investments, so that a single failure does not lose you everything.

From memory: why does a fragile borrower offer a higher coupon? And what does diversifying mean?

The life of a diversified basket

With real investments, the baskets are not all the same. Follow Prisca's 30,000 FCFA through a bad year.

The life of a diversified basket1/7

Thirty thousand francs

Prisca has saved 30,000 F. She splits it into three baskets: 30,000 ÷ 3 = 10,000 F each.

Prisca's result, step by stepFictional

  1. The split. 30,000 ÷ 3 = 10,000 FCFA in each basket: a share, a bond, an account.
  2. The share. A bad year: it is now worth only 6,000 FCFA, and pays no dividend.
  3. The bond. Still worth 10,000 FCFA, and it paid a 600 FCFA coupon: 10,000 + 600 = 10,600 FCFA.
  4. The account. 10,000 FCFA, unchanged.
  5. The total. 6,000 + 10,600 + 10,000 = 26,600 FCFA. She has lost 30,000 − 26,600 = 3,400 FCFA.

Had she put everything into the share, she would have 3 × 6,000 = 18,000 FCFA: a loss of 12,000 FCFA.

When all the baskets fall together

Diversifying works because one piece of bad luck does not hit every basket at once. But look closely at the word "different" in the definition.

Imagine three shares in three shops at the same market. If the market is closed for a month, all three shops sell less at the same time: the three baskets fall together. You have three baskets, but really only one bet.

Diversifying well therefore means choosing investments that do not depend on the same thing: a share and a bond, companies in different trades, a little money that does not move.

Diversifying reduces risk, but does not remove it. Even with six baskets, a falling basket loses you eggs. Anyone who promises you a big return with no risk at all is mistaken or is misleading you.

Without scrolling up: why are three shares in three shops at the same market not good diversification?

Your turn

An issuer riskier than the others usually offers a coupon...

1An issuer riskier than the others usually offers a coupon...

You spread 12 eggs across 4 baskets. A basket falls. How many eggs do you have left?

2You spread 12 eggs across 4 baskets. A basket falls. How many eggs do you have left?

Diversifying your investments means...

3Diversifying your investments means...

You put 10,000 FCFA into each of three investments, 30,000 FCFA in all. Only one loses half its value. What is left?

4You put 10,000 FCFA into each of three investments, 30,000 FCFA in all. Only one loses half its value. What is left?

Three shares in three shops at the same market are...

5Three shares in three shops at the same market are...

Read next: AMF, « Investir dans les obligations » (2023)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further