Saving, investing, speculating
Putting aside, earning over time, betting on the price: three intentions not to confuse.
Lesson 108 min
By the end of this lesson
- Tell saving, investing and speculating apart by the buyer’s intention
- Work out a tontine’s pot from what each member pays in
- Explain why inflation makes money in a piggy bank buy less
In this lesson5
Three friends, three birthdaysFictional
Three friends each receive 10,000 FCFA for their birthday. The first puts it in a money box. The second buys a share to receive dividends for years. The third buys a share on Monday hoping to sell it at a higher price on Friday.
They are not doing the same thing at all.
Three words, three intentions
- Saving means putting part of your money aside instead of spending it. The money box, the bank account, the neighbourhood tontine: that is saving.
- Investing means putting that money into a project so that it earns over time: a share that pays dividends, a bond that pays coupons.
- Speculating means buying while betting that the price will rise fast, to sell at a higher price. You no longer care what the company makes, only about the price movement.
Savings
Money put aside instead of being spent.
Investment
Putting money into a project, a share or a bond so that it earns over time.
Speculation
Buying while betting on a quick rise in price, to sell at a higher price soon after.
The life of some savings
Savings do not have to stay in the money box. Follow Junior's coins, from his pocket to his first coupon.
A coin put aside
Every week Junior keeps 2,000 F instead of spending it. That is saving.
Junior's tontine, step by stepFictional
Ten friends each pay in 2,000 FCFA a week. Each week one of them takes the whole pot, in turn.
- The pot. 10 × 2,000 = 20,000 FCFA every week.
- Alone. To gather 20,000 FCFA at 2,000 FCFA a week, it would take 20,000 ÷ 2,000 = 10 weeks.
- The first to be served receives 20,000 FCFA in the very first week. He has paid in 2,000 FCFA so far; he still owes 9 × 2,000 = 18,000 FCFA. For him, it is like a loan from his friends, with no interest.
- The last to be served has paid in 10 × 2,000 = 20,000 FCFA before receiving the pot. For him, it is pure saving.
The tontine adds no money: everyone receives exactly what they paid in. It only changes when you have the large sum.
From memory: what is the difference between investing and speculating?
Why not keep everything in the money box?
Because prices go up over time. The Banque de France calls this inflation: a lasting, general rise in prices; with it, the same amount of money buys fewer things (Banque de France, "Inflation and deflation").
The money box and the riceFictional
With 10,000 FCFA, you buy 10 kilos of rice at 1,000 FCFA a kilo.
Two years later, a kilo costs 1,250 FCFA. Your 10,000 FCFA, left in the money box, now buy only 10,000 ÷ 1,250 = 8 kilos.
Saving remains the first step: without money put aside, you cannot invest anything. Investing then lets those savings work, with the risk seen in the previous lesson. The next lesson comes back to inflation in detail.
The same purchase, two intentions
Here is the case that often misleads. Two people buy the same share, on the same day, at the same price. One invests, the other speculates. How is that possible?
It is not the thing bought that makes the difference, it is the intention. The one who invests is counting on the dividends and on the company's life over years. The one who speculates is only counting on a quick price rise, to sell in a few days. If the price falls the following week, the first waits; the second has lost his bet.
Your turn to sort
Every month, Junior pays 5,000 FCFA into his neighbourhood tontine.
Speculating means betting on price movements that are very hard to predict. This portal explains how the stock exchange works; it gives no advice on how to "win on the stock market".
Without scrolling up: two people buy the same share on the same day. What lets us say one invests and the other speculates?
Your turn
Read next: Banque de France, ABC de l’économie, « Inflation et déflation »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.