Skip to content
Criée

Diversifying: correlation matters more than number

Investments that do not move together reduce risk; the risk of the whole market remains.

Lesson 49 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Interpret a correlation coefficient between −1 and +1
  • Work out the value of a basket of two investments after one year
  • Identify systematic risk, which diversification does not remove
In this lesson4

Having ten investments does not protect you if all ten fall on the same day. What matters is not the number of baskets, but how they move relative to each other. What this lesson teaches: judging diversification by the correlation between investments, and knowing which risk it never removes.

Diversifying across and within asset classes

The SEC defines diversification as spreading money among different investments to reduce risk (Investor.gov). FINRA, the self-regulatory authority for US brokers, adds: diversify across asset classes (shares, bonds, cash) and within each one (several companies, several sectors, several issuers) (FINRA, "Asset Allocation and Diversification").

Diversification

Spreading your money across several different investments, so that a single failure does not lose you everything.

Correlation: do they move together?

The OpenStax open finance textbook explains that a correlation coefficient describes how two variables move relative to each other: it is 1 when they move perfectly in the same direction, −1 when they move exactly opposite each other (OpenStax, Principles of Finance, 15.2). The same textbook notes that shares in the same industry tend to be more strongly correlated than those in very different industries.

Correlation

A measure, from −1 to +1, of how much two investments tend to rise and fall at the same time.

Kapok is an invented shop. Pair it with three possible partners, half and half, and watch the black curve of the basket.

Two investments, one basket
The partner moves:
InvestmentWorst yearAfter 8 years
Kapok (shop)−12.0%124,748 FCFA
Partner−12.0%125,367 FCFA
50/50 basket−11.0%125,105 FCFA

Correlation: 0.98

Fictitious annual returns. A correlation measured on the past promises nothing for the future.

A year of falls, step by stepFictional

You invest 50,000 FCFA in Kapok and 50,000 FCFA in a partner. This year, Kapok makes −10%.

  1. A partner in the same industry, −12%. Kapok: 50,000 × 0.90 = 45,000. Partner: 50,000 × 0.88 = 44,000. Total: 89,000 FCFA, i.e. −11%. Almost as bad as Kapok alone.
  2. A partner that moves the other way, +12%. Kapok: 45,000. Partner: 50,000 × 1.12 = 56,000. Total: 101,000 FCFA, i.e. +1%.
  3. What changed. Neither Kapok nor the sum invested; only the correlation between the two investments.

From memory: is a correlation close to +1 between two investments good diversification?

The risk that remains

OpenStax distinguishes two risks. The risk specific to a company (a lawsuit, a failed product, accounting fraud) shrinks when you hold several companies; an average investor can build a reasonably diversified portfolio with about a dozen shares. But there is a level below which risk no longer falls: systematic risk, the risk of the market as a whole, which diversification cannot eliminate (OpenStax, 15.2).

Systematic risk

The risk that hits the whole market at once and that diversification does not remove.

In Central Africa

Two sourced facts show the limits of diversifying only locally.

  • At the end of 2025, the BVMAC had six companies listed in its equity segment (BVMAC annual report 2025): OpenStax's dozen shares does not exist on the regional list alone. Bonds, mostly government bonds, take up a much larger place there: 99.405 billion FCFA of coupons paid in 2025, according to the same report.
  • All investments denominated in CFA francs share the same currency risk. On 12 January 1994, the CFA franc was devalued by 50%: a pension in CFA francs lost half its value once converted into French francs (ministerial answer published in the JO Sénat, 1998; Banque de France, 2025). Since the euro was created, the parity has been fixed: 1 euro = 655.957 FCFA. This historical example predicts nothing; it shows that one shock can hit all investments in the same currency at once.

A correlation is measured on the past and can change. Diversifying reduces risk without ever removing it; an investment presented as "risk-free and highly profitable" should alarm you.

Without looking above: which risk remains when you already hold a dozen shares from different industries?

Your turn

A correlation of −1 between two investments means they...

1A correlation of −1 between two investments means they...

Which addition best diversifies a portfolio of bakery shares?

2Which addition best diversifies a portfolio of bakery shares?

50,000 FCFA in A (−20%) and 50,000 FCFA in B (+10%). What is the whole worth?

350,000 FCFA in A (−20%) and 50,000 FCFA in B (+10%). What is the whole worth?

Diversification cannot eliminate...

4Diversification cannot eliminate...

The 1994 devaluation of the CFA franc mainly illustrates a risk...

5The 1994 devaluation of the CFA franc mainly illustrates a risk...

Read next: OpenStax, Principles of Finance, 15.2 « Risk and Return to Multiple Assets »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further