Valuing with discounted cash flows
A company is worth the money it will produce, brought back to today. The rate chosen and the terminal value weigh heavily.
Lesson 610 min
By the end of this lesson
- Discount a future sum at the chosen discount rate
- Calculate a terminal value with constant growth
- Explain how much the rate and the terminal value weigh in the result
In this lesson4
A thousand francs promised in five years is worth less than a thousand francs today: today's money could be invested, and the promise may not be kept. The discounted cash flow method takes this idea all the way: a company is worth the sum of the money it will produce, each sum brought back to its value today. What this lesson teaches: discounting forecast cash flows, adding a terminal value, and measuring how much the result depends on the rate chosen.
Bringing a future franc back to today
The OpenStax textbook gives the formula for the present value of a future sum: PV = FV ÷ (1 + r)ⁿ, where r is the discount rate and n the number of years; present value is "the value today of tomorrow's cash flow" (OpenStax, 7.4). It is the reverse of the compound interest seen in the Investing section (Compound interest, or the snowball).
Writing for the present value and for the future sum:
Discounting
The calculation that brings a future sum back to its value today, by dividing it by (1 + rate) once for every year of waiting.
Discount rate
The annual return demanded by those who finance the company for waiting and for bearing the risk. The higher it is, the less a distant cash flow is worth today.
For example, 1,100 F received in a year, at a rate of 10%, is worth 1,100 ÷ 1.10 = 1,000 F today.
From memory: what is 121 F received in two years worth today, at a rate of 10%?
The method in four moves
According to OpenStax, the method projects each year's cash flows, discounts them at the required rate, adds a terminal value, sums them, then divides by the number of shares (OpenStax, 11.3).
- Forecast free cash flows over a few years: operating flow minus the investment required (lesson 3).
- Discount them one by one.
- Add a terminal value for all the following years. The usual model assumes constant growth g after the last year: terminal value = next year's cash flow ÷ (r − g), which only makes sense if r is greater than g. It is then discounted like a cash flow in the last year.
- Move to shareholders: the sum gives enterprise value; take off net debt, then divide by the number of shares.
Writing for the free cash flow in year , for the last forecast year, for the discount rate, for the constant growth afterwards, for the terminal value and for enterprise value:
Terminal value
The value, at the end of the detailed forecast period, of all the cash flows in later years, summed up by an assumption of constant growth.
The rate changes everything
Okoumé, a fictional company, forecasts five cash flows. Change the rate and watch the green bars melt, and the terminal value take up almost all the room.
At the top, the forecast cash flow; in green, its value today: the further away, the more it melts.
Enterprise value
- Five years discounted
- 448 M FCFA
- Discounted terminal value
- 1,108 M FCFA
- Per share, net debt deducted
- 1,256 FCFA
Fictional assumptions: 2% growth a year after year 5, net debt of 300 M FCFA, 1,000,000 shares.
Okoumé at a 10% rate, step by stepFictional
Forecast free cash flows, in millions of FCFA: 100, 110, 120, 130, 140. Growth of 2% a year afterwards. Net debt 300; 1,000,000 shares.
- Year 1: 100 ÷ 1.10 = 90.9. Year 2: 110 ÷ 1.21 = 90.9. Year 3: 120 ÷ 1.331 = 90.2. Year 4: 130 ÷ 1.4641 = 88.8. Year 5: 140 ÷ 1.6105 = 86.9.
- Sum of the five years: 90.9 + 90.9 + 90.2 + 88.8 + 86.9 = 447.7.
- Terminal value: the year 6 cash flow is 140 × 1.02 = 142.8; 142.8 ÷ (0.10 − 0.02) = 1,785. Discounted over five years: 1,785 ÷ 1.6105 = 1,108.3.
- Enterprise value: 447.7 + 1,108.3 = 1,556.0. The terminal value makes up 71% of it.
- Shareholders: 1,556.0 − 300 = 1,256.0 million, i.e. 1,256 FCFA per share.
At 8%, you get about 1,793 FCFA per share; at 12%, 935; at 14%, 721. Six points of rate move the value by more than double.
Why so much caution
- The result is only as good as its assumptions. OpenStax warns that the model "is only as good as the information entered" ("garbage in, garbage out") (OpenStax, 11.3).
- The terminal value dominates. In the example, more than two thirds of the value rests on years nobody forecasts in detail.
- r and g are close. When g gets near r, the denominator (r − g) becomes tiny and the value shoots up.
- Cross-check methods. OpenStax advises using several methods to value a company. Here, the multiples in lesson 5 gave 700 to 1,140 FCFA; discounted cash flows give 721 to 1,793 depending on the rate. The overlap says more than a single figure.
The link with interest rates is direct: when a central bank raises its rates, the discount rate goes up and share values fall, with cash flows unchanged (Central banks and interest rates).
A discounted cash flow value is neither a guaranteed price nor investment advice. It depends on forecasts and on a rate that two serious analysts can set differently. Be wary of any presentation that shows a single "fair value" without showing its assumptions.
Without looking back: a cash flow of 50 is expected next year, then grows by 2% a year forever. At 12%, what is this stream worth today?
Your turn
Read next: OpenStax, Principles of Finance, 11.3 « Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Model »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.