Speculation and leverage
A small stake, a large position: gains and losses are multiplied, and the loss can exceed the stake.
Lesson 68 min
By the end of this lesson
- Work out the leverage of a position from the margin deposited
- Work out the result of a leveraged position as a share of the stake
- Explain why the loss on a leveraged position can exceed the stake
In this lesson2
The cooperative in the previous lesson needed someone to take on the risk it was giving up. That someone is often a speculator, and what attracts them is the initial margin: with little money, they take a large position. What this lesson teaches: leverage multiplies the result relative to the stake, in both directions, and the loss can exceed the stake.
Leverage, in one definition
Leverage
A technique that lets you take a position larger than the sum invested, and that amplifies gains and losses alike (AMF, leverage).
On a future, leverage comes from the margin: the CFTC defines leverage as the ability to control large amounts with comparatively little capital (CFTC glossary). In lesson 4, Rosine controlled 15,000,000 F of cocoa with 1,200,000 F: a leverage of 15,000,000 ÷ 1,200,000 = 12.5.
In plain wordsThe lorry of plantain on credit
A trader buys a lorry-load of plantain while paying only a tenth of the price herself; the wholesaler advances the rest. If the price of plantain rises by a tenth, she doubles her stake. If it falls by a tenth, her whole stake is gone. If it falls further, she still owes the wholesaler money. That is leverage: with little money you carry a large quantity, and every change in the price hits your stake ten times harder, in either direction.
Writing for the size of the position, for the stake, for the leverage, for the percentage change in the price and for the result as a percentage of the stake:
A 5% fall, a 50% lossFictional
Patrice deposits 1,000,000 F and takes a 10,000,000 F position on a fictional future: leverage 10.
- The price falls 5%. The position loses 10,000,000 × 5% = 500,000 F.
- Relative to the stake: 500,000 ÷ 1,000,000 = 50%. Half his stake has gone.
- The price falls 10%. The position loses 1,000,000 F: the whole stake.
- The price falls 12%. The position loses 1,200,000 F. 200,000 F is missing: Patrice still owes it.
- The rule: loss as a percentage of the stake = price change × leverage.
Change the leverage and the price move. Watch when the gauge drops below zero.
Leverage: position size per 1 F staked
Price change
Stake 1,000,000 F · position 10,000,000 F
The price moves −5%; the 10,000,000 F position moves −500,000 F, i.e. −50% of the stake. 500,000 F is left.
From memory: with a leverage of 20, how far must the price fall to wipe out the whole stake?
Speculating is useful and risky
The speculator neither produces nor buys cocoa. They take on the risk the hedgers give up, hoping to be paid for it. Without them, the cooperative would have to wait for a chocolate maker wanting exactly the opposite position, at the same moment. That usefulness does not make speculation safe for the person doing it.
This is not investment advice. The AMF points out that "the investor can lose more than their initial investment if the price moves against them" (AMF). On leveraged products sold to retail clients, CFDs, European authorities found that 74 to 89% of retail accounts lost money, with average losses of €1,600 to €29,000 per client; ESMA therefore capped leverage, from 30 to 1 on major currency pairs to 2 to 1 on crypto-assets, and imposed negative balance protection so that retail clients cannot lose more than their stake on these products (ESMA, 27 March 2018). This European protection does not apply to every product or in every country. A promise of high, quick gains with little money describes exactly high leverage: a risk of high, quick losses.
Without looking back: what share of retail accounts lost money on CFDs according to European regulators' data, and what leverage cap did ESMA set for major currency pairs?
Your turn
Read next: AMF, « Effet de levier »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.