1929 and the birth of market regulators
After the crash, the US laws of 1933 and 1934 and the SEC; then the COB in 1967, the CREPMF in 1996 and the COSUMAF in 2001.
Lesson 69 min
By the end of this lesson
- Link the 1929 crash to the two US laws of 1933 and 1934
- Distinguish what the 1933 law requires from what the 1934 law creates
- Date the COB, the CREPMF and the COSUMAF
In this lesson4
For three centuries, exchanges were mostly governed by their members and by one-off state decisions, such as the Paris decree of 1724. After the 1929 crash, the United States created something different: a law requiring the truth about what is being sold, then a permanent authority, separate from the exchange, to enforce it. What you will take from this lesson: how to tell these two responses apart, and how to follow this model from New York to Libreville and Abidjan. How the crash itself unfolded is in the lesson “Crashes: 1929, 2008, 2020”.
The crash in four figures
According to the Federal Reserve, the Dow Jones peaked at 381.17 points on 3 September 1929. On Monday 28 October, it lost nearly 13%, on Tuesday 29 nearly 12%. On 8 July 1932, it closed at 41.22 points, 89% below its peak. Many buyers had bought on credit: they put up “typically 10%” of the price and borrowed the rest (Federal Reserve History).
Crash
A very large and very fast fall in prices across a whole market, when selling overwhelms buying.
Buying with 10% of your own moneyFictional
Abel (fictional) buys 1,000,000 FCFA of fictional shares: he puts up 10%, or 100,000 FCFA, and borrows 900,000 FCFA.
- A 13% fall in one day. His shares are worth 1,000,000 × 0.87 = 870,000 FCFA.
- What he still owes. 900,000 FCFA to the lender.
- What he has left. 870,000 − 900,000 = −30,000 FCFA: his 100,000 stake has gone and he still owes 30,000 FCFA.
- What follows. The lender demands cover: Abel sells, and his sales add to everyone else’s.
1933: telling the truth about what is sold
The Securities Act of 1933, nicknamed the “truth in securities” law, has two objectives, according to the SEC: that investors receive financial and other significant information about securities offered for public sale, and to prohibit deceit and fraud in the sale of securities (SEC, Investor.gov). The law targets the moment a company sells its securities to the public: it requires information, not a price.
1934: a permanent authority
With the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Congress created the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The Act gives it broad authority over the whole industry: registering, regulating and overseeing brokerage firms, transfer agents, clearing agencies and the exchanges themselves, including the NYSE (SEC, Investor.gov). The SEC describes itself as created “at the height of the Great Depression”, to protect investors, maintain fair, orderly and efficient markets, and facilitate capital formation (SEC, mission).
Market regulator
A public body, separate from the exchange, that sets disclosure rules, licenses intermediaries, monitors trading and punishes breaches.
What is new is the separation. Until then, an exchange’s members wrote and enforced their own rules, such as the fines in the 1817 constitution (lesson 4). Since 1934, the exchange has remained a self-regulatory organisation, but under the control of an authority that does not trade on it.
From memory: what does the 1933 law require, and what does the 1934 law create?
Then elsewhere, all the way to the franc zone
- France, 1967. The Commission des opérations de bourse (COB) was created by ordinance on 28 September 1967; in 2003, it merged with the CMF and the CDGF to form the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) (La finance pour tous).
- UEMOA, 1996. The agreement of 3 July 1996 created the Regional Council for Public Savings and Financial Markets (CREPMF), which became the AMF-UMOA on 1 October 2022 (AMF-UMOA, history).
- CEMAC, 2001. The Central African Financial Market Supervisory Commission (COSUMAF) was created by the Additional Act of 8 December 2001. It looks after “the protection of savings”, “investor information” and “the proper functioning of the Regional Financial Market” (Regulation no. 01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF).
COSUMAF
The Central African financial market supervisory commission: it protects savings and grants or withdraws licences.
AMF-UMOA
The UMOA Financial Markets Authority, in Abidjan, called the CREPMF until 1 October 2022: it protects savings, grants visas and licences, inspects and sanctions.
The same two ideas as in 1933 and 1934 appear in the COSUMAF’s missions: inform the investor, and hand supervision to a body that is not the exchange. What it does today is the subject of the lesson “The COSUMAF: license, inspect, sanction”.
- 1929
Wall Street crashAmericas
The Dow Jones loses nearly 13% on 28 October and nearly 12% on the 29th.
- 1932
The low pointAmericas
41.22 points on 8 July, 89% below the peak.
- 1933
Securities ActAmericas
Compulsory information on securities offered to the public.
- 1934
Birth of the SECAmericas
A permanent authority oversees brokers and exchanges.
- 1967
COBEurope
France creates its Commission des opérations de bourse on 28 September.
- 1996
CREPMFAfrica
Agreement of 3 July: the regulator of the UEMOA regional market.
- 2001
COSUMAFAfrica
Additional Act of 8 December: the regulator of the CEMAC market.
- 2003
AMFEurope
The COB merges into the Autorité des marchés financiers.
- 2022
AMF-UMOAAfrica
The CREPMF changes its name on 1 October.
Without looking back: put the COB, the COSUMAF, the SEC and the CREPMF in order.
For the CREPMF, the BRVM dates its installation to 20 November 1997, while the AMF-UMOA dates its founding agreement to 3 July 1996: this lesson uses the AMF-UMOA’s date for its own history. The COSUMAF’s seat in Libreville is confirmed by the decision of 31 October 2017, reported by the press and by the BVMAC’s timeline; the COSUMAF’s website could not be consulted.
Your turn
Read next: SEC, Investor.gov, « The Laws That Govern the Securities Industry »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.