A cocoa cooperative hedges
Selling futures in March fixes December’s income, whatever the world cocoa price.
Lesson 59 min
By the end of this lesson
- Choose the futures position that hedges a seller against a fall
- Work out the gain or loss on the futures of a selling hedge
- Identify the basis and the currency risk that remain
In this lesson3
A cooperative that sells cocoa fears a fall. It can protect itself without signing with a particular buyer: all it has to do is sell futures today, then buy them back on the day it sells its crop. What this lesson teaches: a futures hedge offsets the loss on the goods with a gain on the contract, and vice versa.
A very restless world price
Cocoa is sold at a world price. According to the International Cocoa Organization, the ICCO indicator price averaged 6,612 dollars a tonne over the 2024/2025 season, about 39% more than the previous season; prices were "exceptionally volatile", rising to unprecedented highs in late 2024 before falling steadily from January 2025 (ICCO, annual report 2024/2025, p. 12). The same report estimates Cameroon's output at 310,000 tonnes for that season.
For a Central African producer, moves like these over a few months can change a whole year's income.
From memory: does a cocoa seller fear a rise or a fall, and what futures position does he take to hedge?
The selling hedge, step by step
A fictional cooperative, Mballa's, expects 20 tonnes for December. In March the "December cocoa" future trades at 1,500 F a kilo. It sells 2 contracts of 10 tonnes at that price. In December it sells its crop at the day's price and buys back its 2 contracts.
Cocoa price in December
The crop brings in only 24,000,000 F, but the futures sold at 1,500 and bought back at 1,200 earn 6,000,000 F. Total: 30,000,000 F.
The price falls to 1,200 FFictional
- The crop: 20,000 kg × 1,200 = 24,000,000 F.
- The futures: sold at 1,500, bought back at 1,200. Gain: (1,500 − 1,200) × 20,000 = 6,000,000 F, received day after day through the margin account.
- The total: 24,000,000 + 6,000,000 = 30,000,000 F.
- The comparison: that is exactly 20,000 × 1,500, the March price.
The price rises to 1,800 FFictional
- The crop: 20,000 × 1,800 = 36,000,000 F.
- The futures: sold at 1,500, bought back at 1,800. Loss: (1,500 − 1,800) × 20,000 = −6,000,000 F.
- The total: 36,000,000 − 6,000,000 = 30,000,000 F. The cooperative has given up the rise.
The aim of a hedge is not to win: it fixes a result. In the second case you must also be able to meet margin calls while the price is rising, before the crop money comes in: a hedge requires cash.
In plain wordsTwo linked jars
In March, the cooperative sells December cocoa on the exchange with no intention of delivering it: in December it will buy the contract back at the day's price. If the price falls, its crop brings in less, but buying the contract back costs less than it sold it for. What it loses on one side comes back on the other, like water flowing between two jars joined by a pipe without a drop being lost. If the price rises, it is the other way round: it gives up the gain. Except that the local price and the exchange price never move quite together, and you need cash to pay the losses on the contract before the crop is sold.
Writing for the quantity hedged, for the price at which the futures were sold and for the final price, assumed to be the same for the cocoa and for the future, the result on the futures and the total received are:
What the example simplifies
The example assumes the future and the cocoa sold locally end at the same price. In reality, three gaps remain:
- the basis: the price paid in Douala or Kribi is not that of an approved warehouse in London or Amsterdam;
- currency: ICE's London Cocoa contract is quoted in pounds sterling (ICE), while the CFA franc is pegged to the euro, at 655.957 francs to 1 euro (Banque de France), not to the pound or the dollar;
- size: 10 tonnes per contract, which does not necessarily fit the crop.
Finally, no reliable source found establishes that CEMAC producers or cooperatives hedge directly on these markets: Mballa's cooperative is fictional.
Without looking back: with 2 futures sold at 1,500 and a final price of 1,350, what are the 20-tonne crop, the futures result and the total worth?
Your turn
Read next: ICCO, rapport annuel 2024/2025
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.