Skip to content
Criée

Why regulate: the price of mistrust

A buyer who fears a hidden loss pays less, even to honest companies. The three objectives of regulation.

Lesson 17 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate the highest price a wary buyer will accept
  • Explain why mistrust penalises sound companies first
  • State the three objectives of regulation and the text behind COSUMAF’s mission
In this lesson4

In a market, the buyer never sees everything the seller knows. If they suspect something is being hidden, they pay less, or they do not buy. That is the first job of regulation: to make trust strong enough for the price to reflect value. What this lesson teaches: putting a figure on the cost of mistrust.

Information asymmetry

The situation where one side of a trade knows something important that the other does not.

What mistrust does to the price

A careful buyer pays at most what they expect on average. If a share is worth 10,000 when all is well and 6,000 when the seller is hiding a loss, the buyer weights the two cases by the chance they give each one.

Writing pp for the probability of a hidden loss, VsV_s for the value if the accounts are sound and VhV_h for the value if a loss is hidden, the highest price accepted is:

Pmax⁡=(1−p) Vs+p VhP_{\max} = (1 - p) \, V_s + p \, V_h
The price of mistrustFictional company and amounts

A share of the fictional company Baobab is worth 10,000 if the accounts are sound, 6,000 if the seller is hiding a loss. What chance does the buyer give to hidden bad news?

Value if everything is disclosed: 10,000

Highest price the buyer will pay: 9,200

(80 × 10,000 + 20 × 6,000) ÷ 100 = 9,200. Mistrust costs 800 FCFA per share, even for honest companies: one really worth 10,000 can no longer find a buyer at its price.

The last line matters most: the discount hits honest companies too. The one whose share is really worth 10,000 can no longer find a buyer at that price; it gives up raising money on the exchange. A market without rules drives away the best issuers, not the worst.

The cost of mistrust, step by stepFictional

A fictional share is worth 10,000 FCFA if the accounts are sound, 6,000 if a loss is hidden. The buyer puts the probability of a hidden loss at 20%.

  1. Good case: 80% × 10,000 = 8,000.
  2. Bad case: 20% × 6,000 = 1,200.
  3. Highest price accepted: 8,000 + 1,200 = 9,200 FCFA.
  4. Discount: 10,000 − 9,200 = 800 FCFA per share, i.e. 8%.

A sound company selling 100,000 shares thus loses 100,000 × 800 = 80,000,000 FCFA of funding, because of a doubt it did not create. Rules that require accounts to be published and punish lying bring the probability back towards 0 and the price back towards 10,000.

From memory: with a one-in-ten chance of a hidden loss, what is the highest price the buyer accepts in the example?

The three objectives of regulation

The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) sets market regulators three objectives: protecting investors; ensuring that markets are fair, efficient and transparent; reducing systemic risk (IOSCO 2017 principles, summarised by the Central Bank of Ireland). Its 38 principles serve as a common reference.

The same ideas are found in the CEMAC zone. Regulation No. 01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF, art. 17, tasks the COSUMAF with ensuring equal treatment of shareholders, the fairness, transparency, honesty, security and integrity of the market, and the protection of investors.

Three objectives, three families of rules

1/3Protect investors

License those who handle savings, deal with complaints, punish fraud.

A lesson from history

In the United States, the SEC, the market regulator, was created in 1934, “at the height of the Great Depression”; its mission is to protect investors, maintain fair, orderly and efficient markets, and facilitate capital formation (SEC, “Mission”). The last point echoes the example: restored trust lets companies raise funds.

Without looking back: what are IOSCO's three objectives of regulation?

What comes next

The following lessons take these objectives one by one: who watches (the COSUMAF), what is banned (insider dealing, manipulation), what is required (company disclosure, knowing your customer), and what an aggrieved saver can do. For how information gets into the price, see the lesson “A price is information” in the economics section.

Your turn

A share is worth 10,000 or 6,000; the buyer fears a hidden loss at 50%. They pay at most...

1A share is worth 10,000 or 6,000; the buyer fears a hidden loss at 50%. They pay at most...

When mistrust pushes prices down, who loses the most?

2When mistrust pushes prices down, who loses the most?

Which is not one of IOSCO's three objectives?

3Which is not one of IOSCO's three objectives?

In the CEMAC, which text tasks the COSUMAF with market integrity?

4In the CEMAC, which text tasks the COSUMAF with market integrity?

The US SEC was created in...

5The US SEC was created in...

Read next: OICV (IOSCO), objectifs et principes de la régulation des valeurs mobilières, 2017

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further