Banks and the capital market
Loan or bond: who carries the risk, when money is created, and why CEMAC banks hold so much government debt.
Lesson 99 min
By the end of this lesson
- Distinguish intermediated and market financing, and who bears the risk
- Determine when financing through securities creates or destroys money
- Calculate the share of coupons that goes to a bank holding bonds
In this lesson3
A company that needs money has two doors: a bank counter, or the capital market, where it sells shares or bonds to investors. The two are often set against each other. In reality, banks are everywhere on the market: they buy securities there, they support issuers, they raise funds there. Once you understand these links, you will be able to say when financing creates money, and why the balance sheets of CEMAC banks are tied to government debt.
Two paths, two ways of carrying the risk
- The bank loan. The bank lends, keeps the loan on its balance sheet and carries the risk. This is intermediated finance.
- The capital market. The company issues securities bought directly by investors, who carry the risk. This is market finance. In CEMAC this market is run by BVMAC and overseen by COSUMAF (regulation no. 01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF, in French).
Intermediated finance
Funding granted by a bank, which keeps the claim on its balance sheet and carries the risk, as opposed to market finance, where the borrower issues securities bought by investors.
The difference is not only about risk. Lesson 2 showed it: a bank loan creates money. A bond bought by savers, on the other hand, only moves existing deposits from their accounts to the issuer's.
When a bank buys a security
The Bank of England explains that deposits are created or destroyed whenever the banking sector buys or sells assets to non-banks. When banks buy government bonds from the non-bank private sector, "they credit the sellers with bank deposits"; conversely, when a bank issues shares or long-term debt bought by non-bank companies, those companies pay with deposits, which destroys money (Bank of England, 2014).
Follow the fictional Moabi bakery, which funds a factory both ways. Watch for when the "created" stamp appears.
Moabi wants a factory
The bakery has grown: it needs 100,000,000 F for a factory. Clarisse has two paths open to her.
How much money does an issue create?Fictional
Moabi issues 100,000,000 F of bonds at 6.5% (fictional). Savers buy 60,000,000 F of them, Iroko Bank 40,000,000 F.
- The savers' share: they pay with their deposits. 60,000,000 F move from their accounts to Moabi's. Money created: 0.
- The bank's share: Iroko pays by crediting Moabi's account. Money created: 40,000,000 F.
- Annual coupons: 100,000,000 × 6.5% = 6,500,000 F, of which 60% to savers (3,900,000 F) and 40% to Iroko (2,600,000 F).
- Had Moabi borrowed 100,000,000 F from the bank, the money created would have been 100,000,000 F.
From memory: one 10 million bond is bought by a household, another by a bank. Which one creates money, and why?
Banks and government debt in CEMAC
CEMAC governments borrow by issuing government securities, and the BEAC statutes provide that it "assists member states in issuing and managing government securities" (statutes, article 21, in French). It is mostly banks that buy them. The IMF notes that banks' exposure to governments, in loans and securities, rose from about 10% of their total assets at the end of 2015 to about 30% at the end of 2024, and recommends preventing primary dealers, "predominantly banks", from absorbing the entirety of sovereign issues (IMF, CEMAC, June 2025).
What 30% of assets meansFictional
A fictional bank has 1,000 billion F of assets.
- End of 2015, at 10%: 100 billion lent to governments or held in government securities.
- End of 2024, at 30%: 300 billion.
- What is left for the rest of the economy, for the same balance sheet: 900 billion before, 700 billion after.
The IMF is concerned precisely about this crowding-out effect: when banks mostly fund governments, there is less credit left for firms and households; and if a government pays badly, the banks are hit at the same time.
This link also explains why a BEAC rate decision matters to banks: when rates rise, the price of the bonds they hold falls. The mechanism is detailed in "The economy and markets" ("Central banks and interest rates"), and bonds themselves in "Financial products" ("Owning or lending: shares and bonds").
Nothing in this lesson is investment advice. A listed bond, even a government one, can lose value if rates rise or if the issuer pays badly; coupons are only paid if the issuer can pay.
Without looking back: why does the IMF want to stop banks absorbing all the issues of CEMAC governments?
Your turn
Read next: Bank of England, « Money creation in the modern economy », Quarterly Bulletin 2014 Q1
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.