Skip to content
Criée

Control and audit: the three lines

Those who do, those who monitor, those who check independently, and the statutory auditor outside.

Lesson 78 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Place each control job in the three lines model
  • Check whether an order exceeds the limit set by the second line
  • Distinguish the role of internal audit from that of the statutory auditor
In this lesson3

An error always happens in the end: one zero too many, a limit raised without approval, an account wrongly reconciled. The question is not to prevent it for certain, but to know who will see it, and when. The skill in this lesson: placing each control job in the three lines model, and placing the statutory auditor outside it.

The three lines model

The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), the worldwide professional body for internal auditors, published its "Three Lines Model" on 20 July 2020 (IIA, Three Lines Model, 2020).

Three lines and a governing body

1/4First line

The roles most directly aligned with serving clients, support functions included: traders, advisers, back office. They own their risks and their controls.

The model states that first and second line roles "may be blended or separated" depending on the organisation's size, but that internal audit's independence rests on three conditions: accountability to the governing body, unfettered access to people and data, freedom from interference (principles 3 to 5).

Internal audit

The function, independent of management, that checks through audits that governance, risk management and controls work, and reports to the board.

The three lines model is a professional reference, not a law. In the CEMAC, what the COSUMAF general regulation requires of market intermediaries is an independent compliance and internal control officer, who submits a report each year to management and the board, also sent to the COSUMAF within three months of the year end (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, art. 287 and 288). The word "line" does not appear in it.

From memory: which line do a trader, a risk controller and an internal auditor belong to?

An error meets the three lines

An error meets the three lines1/7
1st lineTrader
2nd lineRisk
2nd lineCompliance
3rd lineInternal auditor
GovernanceBoard
ExternalStatutory auditor

One zero too many

A client wants 600 shares. The trader types 6,000. Amount: 30,600,000 FCFA. She has not noticed.

One zero too many, then a sampleFictional

A client wants 600 shares at 5,100 FCFA. The trader types 6,000.

  1. The amount entered. 6,000 × 5,100 = 30,600,000 FCFA.
  2. The second-line control. The limit per order is 5,000,000 FCFA. 30,600,000 > 5,000,000: the order is blocked before the market.
  3. The corrected amount. 600 × 5,100 = 3,060,000 FCFA, under the limit: the order goes.
  4. The audit, months later. The auditor samples 40 orders at random and finds 2 limit increases without a second signature: 2 ÷ 40 = 5% of the sample.
  5. The decision. He fixes nothing himself; he recommends, and the board imposes the second signature.

The second-line control saved the order; the audit found the weakness that could have let it through another day.

The statutory auditor, outside

The statutory auditor belongs to no line: they are outside the company. A public limited company that makes a public offering appoints at least two (OHADA Uniform Act on commercial companies, art. 702). In the CEMAC, those who work for such companies and for supervised entities are licensed by the COSUMAF and registered with the chartered accountants' body of a member state; in their report, they certify that the accounts are regular and fair, certify them with reservations, or refuse to certify (COSUMAF General Regulation 2023, art. 162 to 164). They also attach their observations to the annual internal control report that the chair of a listed company sends to the COSUMAF within 90 days of the year end (art. 166).

Statutory auditor

The independent professional who checks and certifies a company's financial statements for its shareholders.

Control jobs are many and can be learnt: risk controller, compliance officer, internal auditor, auditor in a firm. All require the same quality, knowing how to say no with evidence. The Company section shows what certified accounts bring to investors.

Without looking back: who does internal audit report to, and why not to management?

Your turn

In the three lines model, compliance is a...

1In the three lines model, compliance is a...

Limit of 2,000,000 FCFA per order. Is an order for 500 shares at 4,200 FCFA blocked?

2Limit of 2,000,000 FCFA per order. Is an order for 500 shares at 4,200 FCFA blocked?

Internal audit finds a control weakness. It...

3Internal audit finds a control weakness. It...

How many statutory auditors, at least, for a public limited company making a public offering?

4How many statutory auditors, at least, for a public limited company making a public offering?

Can the statutory auditor refuse to certify the accounts?

5Can the statutory auditor refuse to certify the accounts?

Read next: IIA, « The IIA’s Three Lines Model » (juillet 2020)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further