What makes money
Unit of account, medium of exchange, store of value: three functions, three forms, and a trust that can falter.
Lesson 18 min
By the end of this lesson
- Recognise the three functions of money in a real situation
- Calculate how many prices barter requires
- Distinguish cash, deposit and electronic money, and the effect of inflation
A 10,000 CFA franc note costs a few francs to print, yet a fishmonger hands you fish in exchange for it. It is not the paper that makes money, it is what money lets you do. Once you understand these three uses, you will be able to say whether something is money, and why it can stop being money.
Three functions, not a material
The Banque de France defines money by its use: for an instrument to count as money, it must perform three functions, "being a unit of account, a medium of exchange and a store of value" (Banque de France, "Monnaie : de quoi parle-t-on ?", in French).
Money
Whatever serves at once as a unit of account (prices are expressed in it), a medium of exchange (you pay with it) and a store of value (you can keep it for later).
- Unit of account. The fish costs 2,500 F, the cloth 8,000 F: very different things are compared with a single yardstick.
- Medium of exchange. Without money you would need barter: the fisherman who wants cloth would have to find a weaver who wants fish, at the same moment. The Banque de France sums it up: an economy based on money is "much more efficient than an economy that relied on barter".
- Store of value. You can sell today and buy in six months. The value you keep is only safe if prices stay stable.
How many exchanges without money?Fictional
A fictional market has 5 traders: fish, cloth, cassava, soap, charcoal.
- With barter, you need the price of each good in terms of every other: fish for cloth, fish for cassava… For 5 goods that makes 5 × 4 ÷ 2 = 10 different prices to remember.
- With money, each good has a single price in francs: 5 prices.
- With 50 goods, barter needs 50 × 49 ÷ 2 = 1,225 prices, money still 50.
It is the unit-of-account function that saves this memory and time.
Writing for the number of goods, barter needs prices, money only .
From memory: what are the three functions of money, and which one removes the barter problem?
Three forms: notes, accounts, phone
The same Banque de France distinguishes three forms: "fiduciary, scriptural, electronic", in plain English cash, deposit money and electronic money.
- Cash (in French monnaie fiduciaire): notes and coins. The French word comes from the Latin fides, which "means trust". In CEMAC it is the BEAC that issues the currency and "guarantees its stability"; it issues the notes and coins that are legal tender (BEAC statutes, article 1).
- Deposit money: entries in bank accounts. It is by far the most plentiful. In the euro area it makes up more than 90% of the money in circulation (Banque de France, "Comment est créée la monnaie ?"); in the United Kingdom the Bank of England counts 97% as bank deposits (Bank of England, 2014).
- Electronic money: money stored in a payment account, for instance on a phone. Lesson 8 is devoted to it.
The share of notes in CEMAC money has not been verified for this lesson. The figures above concern the euro area and the United Kingdom; do not transfer them as they are to Central Africa, where cash is used more.
Follow a note from its birth to its return to the bank. At each step, look at which function it performs, and in which form the money is.
The note is issued
The BEAC issues the notes that are legal tender in CEMAC. A 10,000 F note is worth almost nothing as paper: its value comes from the trust of those who accept it.
Remember the withdrawal step: when Nadège withdraws 10,000 F, she does not have more money. Her deposit falls by the same amount. Changing form does not create money.
When trust falters
Money is only worth something if people believe it will be accepted tomorrow at the same price. If prices rise fast, the store-of-value function breaks first: everyone gets rid of their notes. For a reminder on inflation, see the lesson "Inflation and the real rate" in "The economy and markets".
The CEMAC CFA franc has a fixed parity: 1 euro = 655.957 CFA francs (Banque de France, "Les coopérations monétaires Afrique-France"). That parity has changed before: in January 1994 the CFA francs were devalued by 50% (same source). Before, 1 CFA franc was worth 0.02 French francs. Overnight, an imported good priced in French francs cost twice as many CFA francs.
What the 1994 devaluation does to a banknoteFictional
A fictional trader imports a radio costing 100 French francs.
- Before: 1 CFA franc = 0.02 French francs, so 1 French franc = 1 ÷ 0.02 = 50 CFA francs. The radio costs 100 × 50 = 5,000 CFA francs.
- After, the value of the CFA franc is halved: 1 CFA franc = 0.01 French francs, i.e. 100 CFA francs per French franc. The radio costs 100 × 100 = 10,000 CFA francs.
- With his 10,000 CFA franc note, he could buy 2 radios before; now he buys only one.
The note has not changed; what it can buy abroad has been halved.
Without looking back: Nadège withdraws 10,000 F from the bank. Does the amount of money she owns increase? Why?
Your turn
Read next: Banque de France, ABC de l’économie, « Monnaie : de quoi parle-t-on ? »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.