A loan creates money
When a bank lends, it writes a new deposit: loans make deposits, and repayment destroys them.
Lesson 29 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain that a bank loan creates a new deposit
- Explain that repaying a loan destroys money
- State the limits on money creation, including monetary policy
In this lesson3
People often picture a bank as a big safe: savers put money in, the bank lends out what they deposited. For most of today's money that picture is wrong. When a bank grants a loan it takes nobody's money: it creates a new deposit. Once you understand this mechanism, you will be able to explain where most money comes from, and why it also disappears.
Loans make deposits
The Bank of England puts it bluntly: whenever a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower's bank account, "thereby creating new money"; banks do not simply, it adds, lend out the deposits that savers place with them (Bank of England, "Money creation in the modern economy", 2014). The Banque de France says the same in a few words: "loans make deposits" (Banque de France, "Comment est créée la monnaie ?", in French).
Money creation
The appearance of new money. Most of it happens when a commercial bank grants a loan: it writes a new deposit into the borrower's account.
In plain wordsThe shopkeeper's voucher
When a bank grants a loan, it does not take anyone else's savings. It writes, on the borrower's account, a sum that did not exist the day before, and the borrower spends it straight away. It is a bit like a voucher from a trusted shopkeeper: if he writes good for one sack of rice and the whole neighbourhood accepts the paper, he has created a means of payment with the stroke of a pen. When the loan is repaid, the sum is wiped out: that money disappears. Except that the bank cannot write without limit: the risk of not being repaid, the rules and the central bank's rates hold it back.
In practice, the bank's balance sheet grows on both sides at once:
- on the assets side, a claim: what the borrower must repay;
- on the liabilities side, a deposit: what the bank owes the borrower, who can spend it at once.
The Banque de France adds that the old theory, according to which deposits always come before loans, "no longer matches reality".
The bank's balance sheet, before and after a loanFictional
The fictional Iroko Bank has 50,000,000 F of deposits and 50,000,000 F of loans and reserves against them. It lends 2,000,000 F to the fictional Moabi bakery.
- Assets: 50,000,000 + 2,000,000 = 52,000,000 F (including the new claim on Moabi).
- Liabilities: 50,000,000 + 2,000,000 = 52,000,000 F (including Moabi's new deposit).
- Other customers' deposits: still 50,000,000 F. Nobody has been debited.
- Money in the economy: +2,000,000 F, because a deposit is money that can be spent.
From memory: when the bank lends 2,000,000 F, where do those 2,000,000 F come from?
Repayment destroys money
The mechanism also runs in reverse. "Just as taking out a new loan creates money, the repayment of bank loans destroys money" (Bank of England, 2014). When Moabi repays, its deposit falls and the bank's claim disappears: both lines are cancelled together. The amount of money in an economy therefore depends on the flow of new loans, minus repayments.
Follow Moabi's loan from the request to the repayment. Watch the stamp on the deposit: created, then destroyed.
Clarisse needs an oven
The fictional Moabi bakery wants a 2,000,000 F oven. Clarisse, its manager, asks her bank for a one-year loan.
One step deserves attention: the payment to the supplier. The deposit leaves Iroko for another bank. Iroko must then settle that sum with the other bank in central bank money, the money in the accounts banks hold at the BEAC. That is the subject of the next lesson, and that is where the central bank holds the banks.
Limited creation
A bank cannot lend without end. The Bank of England sorts the limits into three groups:
- The bank itself. It must lend profitably against competitors, and manage the risk that the borrower does not repay. The Banque de France adds regulation: reserve requirements in proportion to deposits and capital in proportion to loans (Banque de France).
- The holders of money. Those who receive the new money may use it to repay other loans, which destroys it at once.
- Monetary policy, the ultimate limit: by setting its rates, the central bank makes credit dearer or cheaper, so more or less in demand.
A bank that lends too cheaplyFictional
Iroko wants to double its lending. To attract borrowers it cuts its rate from 9% to 6%. Its deposits cost it 3% (fictional), because it must pay interest on them to stop customers leaving.
- Margin before: 9 − 3 = 6 points on each franc lent.
- Margin after: 6 − 3 = 3 points.
- On 2,000,000 F lent for a year: 120,000 F of margin before, 60,000 F after. If one borrower in thirty does not repay, the expected loss is 2,000,000 ÷ 30 ≈ 66,667 F: the loan is no longer profitable.
Competition and risk curb money creation well before any rule does.
Without looking back: name the three groups of limits on money creation, and say which one the Bank of England presents as the ultimate one.
Your turn
Read next: Bank of England, « Money creation in the modern economy », Quarterly Bulletin 2014 Q1
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.