Fees: compound interest in reverse
1% a year looks small: over 20 years, it is nearly a fifth of the final savings. Comparing returns net of fees.
Lesson 68 min
By the end of this lesson
- Work out what remains invested after entry fees or annual fees
- Explain why the gap caused by fees exceeds the total fees taken
- Compare two investments by their return net of fees
In this lesson4
An annual fee of 1% looks tiny. But it is taken every year from a sum that grows, and the money taken earns nothing more. What this lesson teaches: working out the effect of an annual fee over 20 years and comparing two investments by their return net of fees.
The three moments when you pay
The notes to the AMF's simulators distinguish fees taken on entry (on the first payment), annual fees, expressed as a percentage and which reduce the return, and exit fees (AMF, "Comprendre nos simulateurs de frais et d'épargne"). For shares, the AMF also mentions custody fees and brokerage fees (AMF guide to listed shares).
Annual fees
A percentage taken every year from the value of an investment, whatever its result.
The AMF gives the calculation method: €100 invested at 4% becomes €104 at the end of the year; 1% in fees taken on 31 December makes 1% × 104 = €1.04; €102.96 is left. Entry fees of 3% on €1,000 leave €970 actually invested.
The SEC's example
The SEC shows the effect of three levels of fees on $100,000 earning 4% a year for 20 years: about $208,000 with 0.25% in annual fees, $198,000 with 0.50%, and $179,000 with 1% (Investor.gov, "Understanding Fees"; SEC, Investor Bulletin). Going from 0.25% to 1% therefore costs nearly $30,000, almost a third of the stake.
From memory: why does a 1% annual fee cost much more than 20 × 1% of the starting stake?
The life of a saving that pays fees
Same method, in CFA francs: 1,000,000 FCFA at 4% gross a year. Every year, a coin goes into the fee box. The red area is everything the fees cost: what they took, plus what those sums would have earned.
Fee box
0 FCFA
- No fees (4% a year)
- With 1.00% fees
- What the fees cost
Year 0: 1,000,000 FCFA
No fees: 1,000,000 FCFA. Gap: 0 FCFA, i.e. the fees taken (0 FCFA) plus what they would have earned had they stayed invested.
A fictitious, constant gross return of 4%, fees taken at each year end on the value reached (the AMF simulator method). Total fees over 20 years: 278,318 FCFA.
1,000,000 FCFA with 1% fees, step by stepFictional
- Year 1. 1,000,000 × 1.04 = 1,040,000 FCFA. Fees: 1% × 1,040,000 = 10,400 FCFA. Left: 1,029,600 FCFA.
- Year 2. 1,029,600 × 1.04 ≈ 1,070,784 FCFA. Fees ≈ 10,708 FCFA. Left ≈ 1,060,076 FCFA.
- Each year amounts to multiplying by 1.04 × 0.99 = 1.0296.
- Year 20. 1,000,000 × 1.0296²⁰ ≈ 1,792,135 FCFA. With no fees: 1,000,000 × 1.04²⁰ ≈ 2,191,123 FCFA.
Gap: 2,191,123 − 1,792,135 = 398,988 FCFA. The fees taken account for only about 278,318 of it; the rest, about 120,670 FCFA, is what they would have earned had they stayed invested.
Comparing two investments
Always compare the return net of fees. An investment A advertising 6% with 2% annual fees does, each year, ×1.06 × 0.98 ≈ ×1.039; an investment B at 5% with 0.5% fees does ×1.05 × 0.995 ≈ ×1.045. The less attractive one on the poster earns more. The SEC advises asking, before investing, for the total fees to buy and sell, the ongoing account fees, and how the professional is paid (Investor.gov).
Writing for the sum invested, for the gross annual return, for the annual fees taken at the end of the year and for the value after years:
Our sources do not allow us to quote the fees charged by brokers in the CEMAC: the calculation method, however, is the same everywhere.
The 4% return in this example is fictitious and constant, which no risky investment guarantees. Fees, on the other hand, are taken whether the investment rises or falls: they are the only part of the result known in advance.
Without looking above: by what number is an investment at 4% gross with 1% annual fees multiplied each year?
Your turn
Read next: SEC, Investor.gov, « Understanding Fees »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.