Skip to content
Criée

Five centuries in one lesson: what does not change

Transferable share, trust, rules, bubbles: four constants from Bruges to Douala; speed, access and oversight, three things that have changed.

Lesson 98 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Recognise the four constants of the exchange in a historical episode
  • Calculate the ratio between two record volumes to measure the change in speed
  • Say what has changed in access to the exchange and in its oversight
In this lesson2

Eight lessons, from Bruges to Douala. This one reads them again at a single glance. What you will take from it: behind the dates, four things do not change (the transferable share, trust, rules, bubbles), and three change a great deal (speed, access, oversight). Knowing how to spot them lets you read any episode, past or still to come.

Four constants

1. A share you can sell on. In 1602, the VOC register said that shares could be transferred; the first known seller, Jan Allertsz., sold his because he could not pay the first instalment (Petram). In 2019, when the DSX joined the BVMAC, its companies’ shares did not change: only the exchange where they could be sold on changed (lesson 8). See “Amsterdam, a share that changes hands”.

Transferable share

A share of capital that can be sold to another investor without the company’s consent and without the company paying the money back.

2. Trust. The Bruges bill of exchange assumes you give credit to the drawer and the drawee (lesson 1). The Buttonwood Agreement aimed, according to the NYSE, to “promote public confidence in the markets” and to ensure deals between trusted parties (NYSE).

3. Written rules. The 1817 New York constitution set fines for disorderly brokers; the 1724 decree created a place called the Bourse in Paris and imposed stockbrokers (lessons 3 and 4). The laws of 1933 and 1934 and the COSUMAF in 2001 carry the same idea further (lesson 6).

4. Bubbles. Tulip mania in 1637, presented in “Amsterdam, a share that changes hands”, the Compagnie des Indes and the South Sea in 1720, Wall Street in 1929: every era has its own. According to Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst, a bubble “needs a plausible story” to last (NBER).

From memory: what are the four constants of the exchange, with one example each?

Three changes

Speed. In 1817, at 40 Wall Street, 30 securities were called twice a day. On 15 December 1886, more than a million shares changed hands in one day for the first time; on 28 October 1997, a billion (NYSE). Writing V1V_1 for the volume on a first date and V2V_2 for the volume on a later date, the ratio rr tells you how many times the volume was multiplied:

r=V2V1r = \frac{V_2}{V_1}

From 1886 to 1997: 1,000,000,000 ÷ 1,000,000 = 1,000. The daily record was multiplied by a thousand in 111 years.

Access. In Bruges, merchants traded among themselves; in 1602, the VOC’s deed opened the subscription to “all residents” of the United Provinces, and 1,143 people subscribed in Amsterdam (Petram). Today, a regional exchange such as the BVMAC serves savers in six countries, and a broker in Niamey or Dakar enters its orders into the BRVM’s central system in Abidjan (AMF-UMOA, market participants).

Oversight. For a long time, members wrote and enforced their own rules. Since 1934 in the United States, 1967 in France, 1996 in the UEMOA and 2001 in the CEMAC, a market regulator separate from the exchange has overseen intermediaries and the exchange itself (lesson 6).

Market regulator

A public body, separate from the exchange, that sets disclosure rules, licenses intermediaries, monitors trading and punishes breaches.

Reading an episode with the gridFictional

In 2031, a fictional company, Manioc Express, lists on a fictional exchange. Its share goes from 2,000 to 9,000 FCFA in three months on the promise of a miracle app, then falls back to 2,500 FCFA. The fictional regulator investigates the information it published.

  1. Transferable share. Shareholders buy and sell among themselves; the company repays nothing.
  2. Bubble. Multiple of the rise: 9,000 ÷ 2,000 = 4.5. Share lost: (9,000 − 2,500) ÷ 9,000 ≈ 72%.
  3. Trust and rules. The inquiry is about whether the information was true: the same question as in 1933.
  4. What has changed. The rise took three months and happened on screen, not a year in the rue Quincampoix; and it is a regulator, not the exchange alone, that investigates.

Without looking back: work out the ratio between 1 billion shares traded in one day in 1997 and 1 million in 1886.

What comes back, what changes
  1. 1370

    TrustEurope

    Bruges publishes exchange rates: everyone sees the same prices.

  2. 1602

    Transferable shareEurope

    VOC shares can change hands.

  3. 1720

    BubblesEurope

    Paris and London: multiplied by 40 and by 8, then collapsed.

  4. 1724

    RulesEurope

    Paris creates its Bourse and imposes stockbrokers.

  5. 1886

    SpeedAmericas

    A million shares in one day in New York.

  6. 1934

    OversightAmericas

    The SEC, the first permanent authority separate from the exchange.

  7. 1997

    SpeedAmericas

    A billion shares in one day in New York.

  8. 2019

    AccessAfrica

    The unified BVMAC serves six countries from Douala.

These four constants and three changes are a reading grid proposed by this lesson, not a historian’s finding. The volume records are those the NYSE publishes about its own history; they say nothing about other venues.

Your turn

On 28 March 1720, Paris restricted trading to stockbrokers. Which constant do you recognise?

1On 28 March 1720, Paris restricted trading to stockbrokers. Which constant do you recognise?

Jan Allertsz. sold his VOC share because he could not pay. Which constant do you recognise?

2Jan Allertsz. sold his VOC share because he could not pay. Which constant do you recognise?

More than a million shares in one day in 1886, a billion in 1997. The record was multiplied by...

3More than a million shares in one day in 1886, a billion in 1997. The record was multiplied by...

A fictional exchange trades 5,000 shares a day in 1990 and 2,000,000 in 2020. The ratio?

4A fictional exchange trades 5,000 shares a day in 1990 and 2,000,000 in 2020. The ratio?

What has changed in the oversight of exchanges since 1934?

5What has changed in the oversight of exchanges since 1934?

According to the VOC’s 1602 deed, who could subscribe?

6According to the VOC’s 1602 deed, who could subscribe?

Read next: NYSE, « History of NYSE »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further