Skip to content
Criée

Price-time priority

Who is served first when several orders are waiting, and why amending your order can cost you your place.

Lesson 410 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Rank a queue of orders by price priority, then time priority
  • Predict how amending an order affects its time priority
  • Explain the role of timestamping when an order is received
In this lesson5

When several buyers are waiting and a seller arrives, who is served first? The answer is a queueing rule with two criteria, and it has a practical consequence: amending your order can cost you your place.

The rule

Execution follows price priority, then time priority: the best price goes first; at equal price, the order that reached the book first goes before. A market order has priority over limit orders (AMF, "Choisir et passer un ordre de bourse"; BVMAC general regulation 2025, art. 159).

Price-time priority

The rule for serving orders: best price first (highest to buy, lowest to sell), then, at equal price, the oldest.

In plain wordsThe queue at the landing beach

Imagine customers waiting at the landing beach for the canoes, to buy fish. When the fisherman arrives, he serves first the one offering the highest price. Between two customers offering the same price, the one who came first goes ahead. If one of them then decides to buy more, she goes back to the end of the queue, or she would be jumping ahead of the others; if she buys less, she keeps her place, since she is in nobody's way. Except that on the stock market, arrival time is not a matter of memory: every order is time-stamped when it is received.

Time is measured from receipt: on the BVMAC, every order is time-stamped as soon as the brokerage firm receives it and sent "from the session following receipt of the order, without netting or aggregation" (BVMAC general regulation 2025, art. 150). A brokerage firm therefore cannot bundle its clients' orders or net them against each other before sending them.

Time stamping

Recording the time an order is received. At equal price, it sets the order's rank.

Rank the queue by hand

Four buyers, one sellerFictional

Buy orders, in order of arrival: Awa 50 at 10,000, Bertrand 30 at 10,050, Chantal 40 at 10,000, Didier 20 at 10,050. Esther sells 70 shares, limited to 10,000.

  1. Price first: Bertrand and Didier (10,050) go ahead of Awa and Chantal (10,000).
  2. Time next: Bertrand arrived before Didier; Awa before Chantal.
  3. Queue: Bertrand, Didier, Awa, Chantal.
  4. Filling the 70 shares: Bertrand 30, Didier 20, Awa 20. Chantal gets nothing.

Check with the engine, then amend Awa's order in three different ways.

The queue of buy ordersRanking and trades computed by the @criee/marche engine
Amend Awa’s order

Amend Awa’s order

  1. 1BertrandArrival 230 × 10,050
  2. 2DidierArrival 420 × 10,050
  3. 3AwaArrival 150 × 10,000
  4. 4ChantalArrival 340 × 10,000

Amending an order can mean losing your place

Amending an order loses time priority if the limit changes or the quantity increases; priority is kept if the quantity decreases (Euronext Trading Manual, 2021, section 2; BVMAC draft instruction No. 2 of 2008, section 2.5).

The logic: reducing your quantity hinders nobody behind you; increasing it would amount to jumping the queue.

  • Awa increases to 60: she drops behind Chantal at 10,000. Esther fills Bertrand, Didier then Chantal; Awa no longer gets anything.
  • Awa raises her limit to 10,050: she moves ahead of Chantal, but behind Didier, who arrived before her amendment.

The life of an amended order

Follow Awa's order, the first to arrive, through three possible amendments. The engine re-sorts the queue each time, then brings in Esther's sale.

The life of an amended order1/5

First to arrive

Awa buys 50 shares at 10,000. Her order is timestamped first of all.

Awa raises her limit from 10,000 to 10,050 and still receives 20 shares. How much does this amendment cost her?

Nuance: raising your limit is not always progress

People often think a more generous price always gets you ahead. That is true against orders at a worse price, not against those already at the new price: at 10,050 Awa ranks behind Bertrand and Didier, who arrived before her amendment. Lesson 3 showed that a limit order waits in the book; this lesson shows that its place in the queue has a value.

What each amendment gets AwaFictional

Starting queue: Bertrand 30 and Didier 20 at 10,050, Awa 50 then Chantal 40 at 10,000. Esther sells 70 shares, limit 10,000.

  1. No amendment: Bertrand 30, Didier 20, then Awa 20 at 10,000. Awa pays 20 × 10,000 = 200,000 XAF.
  2. Reduce to 30: same rank, same fill, 20 shares at 10,000. Nothing is lost.
  3. Raise to 60: Awa drops behind Chantal. After Bertrand and Didier, Chantal takes the remaining 20 shares; Awa receives 0.
  4. Raise the limit to 10,050: Awa moves ahead of Chantal but behind Didier. She receives 20 shares at 10,050, i.e. 201,000 XAF: 1,000 XAF more than without the amendment, for the same quantity.

The loss-of-priority rule cited for the BVMAC comes from a 2008 draft instruction. Our sources found no current BVMAC text restating it; the price-then-time principle itself is confirmed by the 2025 regulation for the priority of market orders and described in the 2008 draft for continuous trading.

Two buy orders at 7,500: the first received at 9:10, the second at 9:05. A third at 7,550 arrives at 10:00. In what order are they served?

Your turn

Two buy orders at the same price. Which is served first?

1Two buy orders at the same price. Which is served first?

Which amendment keeps an order's time priority?

2Which amendment keeps an order's time priority?

Asks: Eva 20 at 3,010 (received first), Hugo 20 at 3,000. A market buy of 20 fills...

3Asks: Eva 20 at 3,010 (received first), Hugo 20 at 3,000. A market buy of 20 fills...

What does a brokerage firm do with an order received from a client?

4What does a brokerage firm do with an order received from a client?

Bids at 500: Ali 30 (first), Bea 20 (second). Ali reduces to 10, then 25 shares are sold. Bea receives...

5Bids at 500: Ali 30 (first), Bea 20 (second). Ali reduces to 10, then 25 shares are sold. Bea receives...

Read next: AMF, « Choisir et passer un ordre de bourse : ce qu’il faut savoir »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further