Expected or surprise
The market reacts to the gap between the announcement and the expectation. Buy the rumour, sell the news.
Lesson 28 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain why only surprise moves a price on the day of an announcement
- Work out the price of a share during a rumour from its probability
- Predict the effect of a denial of widely expected news
In this lesson4
A company announces record profits and its share price falls. Another announces a loss and its price rises. This is not absurd: the market does not react to the news itself, but to the gap between the news and what it expected. That is what this lesson teaches.
Surprise
The gap between what is announced and what the market expected. Only the surprise moves the price; the expected part is already in it.
News nobody expected
Follow the order book of Kapok (a fictional company) when an unexpected contract comes in. Each order keeps its place from one step to the next: watch it slide to its new limit. The equilibrium price is recalculated at each step by the site's engine.
- Awa 4010,200Hervé 50
- Chantal 3010,100Didier 30
- Fabrice 5010,000Esther 40
- Grâce 309,900Bertrand 30
Computed by the @criee/marche engine (auction)
70 shares traded
A quiet day. Orders cluster around 10,000 CFA francs.
Nobody had moved their orders before the announcement: the whole effect arrives at once, at the next auction.
The same news, expected
Take the same story, but this time a rumour goes round before the announcement. Many believe it and move their orders before it is official.
- Awa 4010,200Hervé 50
- Chantal 3010,100Didier 30
- Fabrice 5010,000Esther 40
- Grâce 309,900Bertrand 30
Computed by the @criee/marche engine (auction)
70 shares traded
A quiet day. Orders cluster around 10,000 CFA francs.
When the news finally comes, it teaches almost nothing. Those who bought on the rumour sell to lock in their gain, and the price slips back. Market practitioners sum this up in a saying: "buy the rumour, sell the news". It is a practitioners' phrase, not a rule: no authority guarantees it, and the rumour may also turn out to be false.
From memory: why did Kapok's price slip back on the day the contract became official?
Putting a figure on an expectation
When news is uncertain, the price sits between what it would be worth if the news happens and what it would be worth otherwise, closer to the case the market judges more likely.
Writing for the probability that the news happens, for the price if it does and for the price otherwise, the price during the rumour is:
A rumour at 80%Fictional
Kapok shares are worth 10,000 CFA francs without the contract and would be worth 11,000 CFA francs with it. Investors put the chance of the contract being signed at 80%.
- The price during the rumour. 0.8 × 11,000 + 0.2 × 10,000 = 8,800 + 2,000 = 10,800 CFA francs.
- If the contract is confirmed. The price goes to 11,000 CFA francs: 11,000 − 10,800 = only +200 CFA francs, because 80% of the news was already in the price.
- If the contract is denied. The price falls back to 10,000 CFA francs: 10,000 − 10,800 = −800 CFA francs.
- What the figures teach. Very expected news lifts the price little if it is confirmed, and drops it a lot if it is not.
Without looking above: the chance of the contract is no longer 80% but 50%. What is the price during the rumour, and what do you gain if the contract is confirmed?
What this changes when you read the news
- "Good" news can lower a price if people expected better; "bad" news can raise it if people feared worse.
- Announcements on a known calendar (annual results, central bank decisions) are often partly in prices before their date. The next lessons show it for rates and for company results.
- To know whether news is a surprise, you need to know what was expected: that is what forecasts published before the announcement measure.
Buying on a rumour means betting on information that is not confirmed. A rumour may be false, or even spread on purpose: the AMF lists "spreading false or misleading information (rumours...)" among price manipulations, and points out that spreading false information is forbidden (AMF, « La surveillance des marchés », our translation). Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.
Your turn
Read next: AMF, « La surveillance des marchés »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.