One company, two venues: cross-listing
A depositary receipt’s parity takes one line to calculate; arbitrage closes the gap down to the fees.
Lesson 78 min
By the end of this lesson
- Calculate a depositary receipt’s parity from the price, the ratio and the exchange rate
- State which way the arbitrageur trades when a receipt moves away from its parity
- Say when fees make an arbitrage not worth doing
In this lesson4
The same company can be listed on two venues. Its shares carry two prices there, in two currencies, but they stand for the same business: those prices cannot drift apart for long. Parity links the two listings, and arbitrage closes the gap; being able to calculate it is what this lesson teaches.
Cross-listing
The admission of the same company to the list of several exchanges, either directly or through certificates that represent its shares.
Why list twice
A company listed on another exchange reaches investors who would not have bought on its home venue. An IMF study of sub-Saharan African companies that listed on another exchange in the region between 1992 and 2008 finds positive abnormal returns around the cross-listing date and concludes that it increases the company's value (IMF, Adelegan, WP/09/99, 2009). It is a working paper: it does not commit the IMF.
The depositary receipt
To be listed in the United States without moving its shares there, a foreign company often uses an American depositary receipt (ADR). The SEC describes it like this: a depositary bank holds the foreign shares; the receipt trades and settles in dollars; it can represent one or more shares, or a fraction of one; its price generally follows that of the share on its home venue, adjusted for that ratio; the depositary bank charges fees (SEC, Investor Bulletin: American Depositary Receipts).
Depositary receipt
A security issued by a depositary bank that holds foreign shares; each receipt represents a fixed number of those shares.
Parity in one line
Receipt parity = local share price × ratio ÷ exchange rate.
Writing for the local share price, for the number of shares a receipt represents (the ratio), for the exchange rate (units of local currency per $1) and for the receipt's parity:
Kapok, listed in Douala and on venue BFictional
Kapok (fictitious) trades at 6,000 XAF in Douala. One receipt represents 10 shares. Fictitious exchange rate: $1 = 600 XAF.
- Value of the shares behind one receipt. 6,000 × 10 = 60,000 XAF.
- In dollars. 60,000 ÷ 600 = $100. That is the parity.
- The receipt trades at $104. It is $4 too expensive, i.e. 4%.
- The arbitrage. Buy 10 shares in Douala, deposit them, sell the receipt at $104: 104 × 600 = 62,400 XAF received for about 60,000 XAF paid.
- The fees. If brokerage, deposit fees and currency exchange cost 1,500 XAF, 62,400 − 60,000 − 1,500 = 900 XAF is left. With 3,000 XAF of fees, the arbitrage is worth nothing.
From memory: write the formula for a receipt's parity, then say which way the arbitrageur acts if the receipt trades above it.
The life of a depositary receipt
Koffi, an arbitrageur, spots the gap. His purchases in Douala go through the order book and are calculated by the portal's engine; the rest follows the example above.
A certificate listed elsewhere
On venue B, one Kapok certificate stands for 10 shares listed in Douala. It trades at $104. Fictitious rate: $1 = 600 XAF.
By buying in Douala, Koffi emptied the first level of the book and paid more for some of his shares: his cost is above 60,000 XAF. That is why the gap never quite closes: a small band always remains, roughly the size of the fees.
Cross-listing adds currency risk to the risk of the share: if the dollar falls against the CFA franc during the operation, the gain can vanish. Nothing here is investment advice. For the CEMAC zone, no cross-listing agreement between the BVMAC and another exchange was found in the sources consulted.
Without looking back: give two reasons why the gap between a share and its receipt does not fall exactly to zero.
Your turn
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.