Skip to content
Criée

Profit is not cash

A profitable company can run short of money. The cash flow statement follows real money: operations, investing, financing.

Lesson 39 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain why a profitable company can run short of cash
  • Calculate operating cash flow from profit, depreciation and changes in receivables
  • Sort a cash flow into its family and work out closing cash
In this lesson4

A company can show a profit and be unable to pay its wages the following month. The OpenStax textbook sums it up in one sentence: "A firm can be profitable and still not have an adequate flow of cash" (OpenStax, 5.5). What this lesson teaches: telling profit and cash apart, and reading the three families of the cash flow statement.

Why a third statement

The income statement records sales and expenses when they happen, not when money moves. A sale payable in 90 days is income today; the money will arrive in three months. The cash flow statement only keeps the money that actually came in or went out: it "traces the 'in' and 'out' movements of cash during the year" (AUDCIF, art. 29).

Cash

The money the company has available straight away: till and bank accounts, minus overdrafts.

Cash flow statement

The statement that explains how cash moved from its opening level to its closing level, sorting the year's money in and out by family.

The life of an invoice

Okoumé, a fictional company, wins a big order payable in 90 days. Watch profit and cash split apart, then come back together.

The life of an invoice1/6

At the start

Okoumé has 30 M FCFA in its account.

The profit of 20 is real, but for three months it sits with the customer as a receivable. A fast-growing company often lives with this gap: the more it sells on credit, the more money it has to advance.

From memory: why is Okoumé overdrawn when its income statement shows a profit?

The three families of cash flows

Article 32 of the AUDCIF sets out what the statement contains: net cash at the start of the year, flows from operating activities, from investing, from equity and from borrowed funds, then net cash at the end of the year (AUDCIF, art. 32). OpenStax groups the last two under the name financing (OpenStax, 5.5).

  1. Operating activities: the money from the business. Start from profit, add back depreciation (an expense with no cash out), then adjust for changes in receivables, inventory and trade payables.
  2. Investing: buying or selling machines, land, stakes in other companies.
  3. Financing: money put in by or returned to shareholders (capital increase, dividends) and lenders (loans, repayments).

The total of the three, added to opening cash, must give back the closing cash shown on the balance sheet.

Writing T0T_0 for opening cash, T1T_1 for closing cash, and FopF_{\text{op}}, FinvF_{\text{inv}}, FfinF_{\text{fin}} for the operating, investing and financing flows:

T1=T0+Fop+Finv+FfinT_1 = T_0 + F_{\text{op}} + F_{\text{inv}} + F_{\text{fin}}

Okoumé's cash flow statement over one yearFictional

Fictional amounts, in millions of FCFA. Cash on 1 January: 40.

  1. Net profit: 70 (previous lesson).
  2. Plus depreciation: + 60, because no cash goes out. That gives 130.
  3. Trade receivables: they go from 50 to 80. The extra 30 has not been collected: − 30.
  4. Inventory: from 30 to 40, i.e. 10 of money tied up: − 10.
  5. Trade payables: from 20 to 25, i.e. 5 not yet paid: + 5. Operating flow: 130 − 30 − 10 + 5 = 95.
  6. Investing: a new press for 80: − 80.
  7. Financing: dividend paid 28, loan repaid 10: − 38.
  8. Total change: 95 − 80 − 38 = − 23. Cash on 31 December: 40 − 23 = 17.

Okoumé is profitable (70), but its cash has shrunk by 23: investment and the dividend cost more than the business brought in.

What the statement reveals

  • A lastingly negative operating flow at a profitable company deserves a question: are customers paying? Is inventory piling up?
  • A dividend paid by borrowing shows up: weak operating flow, financing that takes in loans and pays out dividends.
  • Strong growth uses up money, even when profitable. That is not a flaw, it is a need to be financed.

Operating flow minus the investment required gives what the company can pay to those who finance it: that is the flow discounted by the method in lesson 6.

The AUDCIF provides a "minimal cash system" for the smallest entities, which do not produce a cash flow statement (art. 11 and 28). Listed companies, for their part, publish the full set of statements, under SYSCOHADA and under IFRS (lesson 8).

Without looking back: trade receivables rise by 15 during the year. Is operating flow higher or lower than profit, and by how much?

Your turn

In operating flow, depreciation is...

1In operating flow, depreciation is...

Repaying a bank loan is a flow from...

2Repaying a bank loan is a flow from...

Profit 50, depreciation 20, receivables +25, no other change. Operating flow?

3Profit 50, depreciation 20, receivables +25, no other change. Operating flow?

Opening cash 30, operating flow 40, investing −50, financing +5. Closing cash?

4Opening cash 30, operating flow 40, investing −50, financing +5. Closing cash?

A profitable company is short of cash. The most likely cause?

5A profitable company is short of cash. The most likely cause?

Read next: OpenStax, Principles of Finance, 5.5 « The Statement of Cash Flows »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further